Skip to content
Tyrant Cop Files YouTube profile picture

Compilation channel

Tyrant Cop Files

Audit Compilation Pro brings you the most intense police activity, real bodycam, and viral police bodycam footage you won’t see anywhere else. From first amendment audit moments to shocking cop demands ID encounters, we break down real police interactions, unlawful detainment, and police misconduct caught on camera. Watch cops get owned, tyrant cops exposed, and powerful civil rights moments where knowledge of the law changes everything. Whether it’s ID refusal, cop watch, or raw body cam and dash cam footage, this channel is built for viewers who want to understand what really happens between cops vs citizens. 👉 Subscribe for daily police videos, audit compilations, and real-world lessons on know your rights.

YouTube @Tyrantcopfiles (opens in a new tab)

Compilation channelYouTube

Type
Compilation channel
Platform
YouTube
Incidents documented on CopFax
220
Departments involved
173
Officers named
4
YouTube subscribers
1,700

Incidents (220)

  • Dallas officer tells sidewalk auditors recording near Starbucks is lawful

    April 7, 2026 · Dallas Police Department · Dallas, TX

    The narrator states that on April 7, 2026, two citizen journalists filmed from a public sidewalk near a Starbucks drive-thru on Turtle Creek in Dallas, Texas. Several customers objected, saying they had not given permission to be recorded. A Dallas PD officer who introduced himself as Officer Beck said someone had called about them. He told them they were on the public roadway and recording in public was fine. He asked them not to cause a disturbance and said some people might be uncomfortable and call police. The auditors thanked him, and the conversation was cordial.

  • Green Cove Springs sergeant responds to sign holder in HOA areaAlso covered

    November 19, 2025 · Green Cove Springs Police Department · Green Cove Springs, FL

    A sergeant responded to calls about a man holding a sign near an active construction area, described as HOA or CDD property. He asked the man for ID and the man declined. The sergeant then contacted the property office and his commander. He told other officers the man was not doing anything wrong, was not asking for money, and had a right to record and hold a sign in public. He said police could do nothing unless the property owner acted or the man caused disturbances.

  • Maryville officer and chief ask recording man for ID outside bank

    December 1, 2024 · Maryville Police Department · Maryville, MO

    The narrator states that in December 2024 a man recording from a public sidewalk near a bank in Missouri was approached by police after a complaint. An officer who identified himself as Officer Myers of the Maryville Police Department asked what the man was doing and asked for his name and ID. The man declined, said he was exercising a right to record, and asked whether he was detained or free to go. A person identified by the narrator as the chief of police said recent ATM theft attempts, where people allegedly photograph ATMs beforehand, were the reason for the call. The man was told he was free to go, said he would stay, and the officers eventually left.

  • Lee's Summit police respond to housing authority lobby after recording and records request

    November 26, 2024 · Lee's Summit Police Department · Lee's Summit, MO

    The narrator states that on November 26, 2024 at the Lee's Summit Housing Authority in Missouri, an independent journalist entered the lobby to submit a Sunshine Law request. Staff objected to his recording, asked him to leave, locked the lobby door, and called police. An officer who gave a surname of Griffin and badge 1207 spoke with staff in an office, and a captain later arrived, said he was glad the citizen was professional, and spoke with staff first. The citizen said he stood in a doorway and was told he could submit the request on blank paper. The captain facilitated the request, and the citizen wrote and submitted it. An officer also said he had no jurisdiction over the post office when asked about a trespass.

  • Hawthorne officers set up tape and dispute distance with recording auditor

    October 13, 2024 · Hawthorne Police Department · Hawthorne, CA

    The narrator states that on October 13, 2024 a citizen journalist filmed Hawthorne police during a stop involving an alleged gun and marijuana. An officer told the auditor he was too close to a criminal investigation and needed to move back, and the auditor asked where the boundary was. Officers then put up crime scene tape, which the auditor said was only placed after his camera arrived and left one side open. The auditor asked an officer for his name and badge number and the officer gave a response that the captions render as a number. The narrator says recording in public is protected, that officers may set reasonable limits, and that the tape placement looked inconsistent.

  • Jacksonville officers detain man filming on sidewalk after anonymous complaint over ID refusal

    January 18, 2024 · Jacksonville Sheriff's Office · Duval County, FL

    The narrator states that on January 18, 2024 in Jacksonville, Florida, a self-described journalist filming on a public sidewalk was stopped after anonymous complaints about a man with a camera. The officers say they are investigating suspicious activity and ask for ID. The man repeatedly asks what crime he is suspected of and refuses to identify himself. A corporal gives his name as Tim Burrow with officer number 674. Officers variously tell him he is free to go, then that he is detained, and an officer says she could arrest him for resist, obstruct, delay. The segment ends with an officer telling him to turn around and face the back.

  • Police speak with man filming near corporate park after security call; man declines to identify

    November 8, 2023 · Fairfax County Police Department · Fairfax County, VA

    The narrator states that a man filming near a corporate park close to a military post was reported to police by security. A security employee asked why he was recording the building and said police would decide whether it was allowed. A police officer then spoke with him in a conversational way and said the call was about his filming. The man said he was recording cars crossing white lines. The officer asked to see his ID, and the man declined. The officer said Virginia is not a stop-and-ID state and that he was not required to, but asked politely and said refusal could draw more attention from others. The man held to his position and the encounter ended courteously.

  • El Paso jail employee takes auditor's phone; deputies cite employee for assault

    October 1, 2023 · El Paso County Sheriff's Office · El Paso County, TX

    The narrator states that in October 2023 outside the El Paso County Jail, a First Amendment auditor claims a jail employee grabbed his phone after objecting to filming. In the audio, the employee tells the auditor he cannot record at a correctional facility and says he will arrest him. The auditor says the man is not a police officer. A deputy gave his name and badge number as Aguilar, 929, and explained that the complaint would go through internal affairs while detectives collect video. The deputy later says the phone was returned and it was not a theft but is a criminal offense. He says the employee will receive a citation. The narrator's later analysis refers to this as an assault citation.

  • Lockport police respond to recording in New York State Department of Labor office

    August 18, 2023 · Lockport Police Department · Lockport, NY

    The narrator states that an auditor recorded in a publicly accessible area of a New York State Department of Labor office in Lockport. Staff told him filming was not allowed and asked him to leave, and then police were called. An officer spoke privately with management for about 10 minutes, then said the main concern was privacy. The auditor declined to give his information, and the officer said he was not forcibly removing him. The auditor asked for a call number and the officer said it would be available at the station after the report was completed. The narrator says a records request for the body camera footage was denied and that a lawsuit followed.

  • NYPD officer tells cameraman he cannot record inside a police vehicle in Harlem

    June 20, 2023 · New York City Police Department · New York City, NY

    The narrator states that on June 20, 2023, on 125th Street in Harlem, an officer told a cameraman he could not record what was inside a city vehicle. The officer said it was a crime because the windows are tinted, but when asked whether it was a misdemeanor or felony, he told the cameraman to look it up. The cameraman asked whether he was being detained, and the officer said he was free to go. The cameraman then said the officer touched him and moved him, and the officer said he was not blocking movement. The cameraman said he was told he was not in handcuffs because it was not a crime, and the narrator notes the officer made no arrest.

  • Orange County deputy orders cameraman to move back from traffic accident scene

    May 10, 2023 · Orange County Sheriff's Office · Orange County, CA

    The narrator states that on May 10, 2023, a First Amendment auditor began recording an Orange County Sheriff's traffic investigation from a public sidewalk. A deputy told the cameraman to stand about 10 feet away behind a small wall and said he could tape as long as he was not in the scene. The deputy said the cameraman was obstructing the investigation and would be handcuffed and taken to Orange County Jail if he did not move. The cameraman said he was far away and the deputy said the cars nearby were involved in the investigation. The narrator says the cameraman eventually moved, and gives the deputy a C+ and the citizen a B.

  • Inglewood City Hall security and police dispute over floor access and filming

    April 24, 2023 · Inglewood Police Department · Inglewood, CA

    The narrator states that on April 24, 2023, an auditor touring Inglewood City Hall in California was blocked by security from going to upper floors. Security staff declined to give names, and the auditor said he did not need an appointment for public floors. Police were called, and officers asked him to leave and said he would be arrested for trespass. The auditor cited the 2018 DHS memo and said a person can only be trespassed if a law was broken. He was handcuffed for trespass, saying he would take the arrest and challenge it later. The auditor also asked two officers for names and badge numbers and criticized a ride-along's attire, citing policy.

  • Hawthorne complaint calls to internal affairs about identification and ride-along policy

    April 18, 2023 · Hawthorne Police Department · Hawthorne, CA

    The narrator states that on April 18, 2023 a citizen contacted Hawthorne Police Department after witnessing what he believed were policy violations during traffic stops. In a recorded exchange, the citizen asked officers why a car was searched and whether the driver consented, and asked for names and badge numbers. He then phoned an internal affairs investigator, read policy sections on ride-alongs and on-duty identification, and made a verbal complaint about an officer who he said did not give his name. The investigator said he would review the videos before answering. The citizen asked about an earlier complaint, and the investigator said it was still in progress.

  • Police respond to reported disturbance at DMV-related office in South Boston, Virginia

    April 17, 2023 · South Boston Police Department · South Boston, VA

    The narrator states that on April 17, 2023, at a DMV-related office in South Boston, Virginia, a citizen trying to resolve a license issue was met by police after a reported disturbance. The citizen said he was not causing a disturbance and called the report retaliation for challenging the agency's handling of his homeless status and address. Officers said dispatch sent them and that one of the staff in the back had called. The citizen also said he had been arrested for driving without a license. The citizen and an officer then argued over jurisdiction and a towed vehicle, and the officers did not arrest him in the footage described.

  • LAPD officers stop man sitting in parked car near his driveway, order passenger out and pat down

    January 23, 2023 · Los Angeles Police Department · Los Angeles, CA

    The narrator states that on January 23, 2023, LAPD officers approached a man sitting in a car near his own driveway and asked about alcohol, parole and probation. Officers said they smelled alcohol, cited an open container and said the car was blocking the driveway apron. An officer asked the man to put down his phone, and he said he wanted to keep recording. He was patted down. The man disputed the parking claim and said he was being profiled as a gang member, and an officer said he could not run his name in a gang file because he lacked access.

  • Los Angeles officers issue parking citation while resident questions them and records badge numbers

    December 24, 2022 · Los Angeles Police Department · Los Angeles, CA

    The narrator states that on December 24, 2022, outside a residence in Los Angeles, a parking citation led to a heated exchange. A man says he was legally parked and asks officers for their names and badge numbers, while the officers say they need a light to identify who they are speaking with. The man criticizes the officers and the department at length, and the officers respond mostly briefly, with one saying not all cops are bad. The narrator's closing commentary says officers provided badge identification and maintained restraint, and grades the citizen C+ and the officers B minus.

  • LAPD officers and bystander dispute over camera and detention on sidewalk

    December 24, 2022 · Los Angeles Police Department · Los Angeles, CA

    The narrator states a tense LAPD encounter began after a citizen claimed officers blocked his camera while another person was detained. A bystander says an officer put a hand in front of his camera and that he did the same back. Bystanders repeatedly ask what the detained person is being arrested for and say a car belongs to a relative. Officers tell the bystanders to get back, and a bystander says he is on the public sidewalk and not in the way of a vehicle leaving. The transcript does not state the outcome or any charge.

  • Santa Ana code enforcement and officers at taco stand dispute with cameraman

    November 24, 2022 · Santa Ana Police Department · Santa Ana, CA

    The narrator states that on November 24, 2022, in Santa Ana, California, code enforcement and police acted against a taco stand while a cameraman recorded from a public sidewalk. The cameraman and an officer each accused the other of blocking the sidewalk. The cameraman asked for names and badge numbers, and officers were heard giving the surname Lopez with numbers 2456 and 3266. An officer was heard saying he would get yellow tape. The cameraman later said the officer touched him with the tape and that he was pushed. The officer was heard saying he was only putting up tape. The narrator criticizes the officers' communication and possible unnecessary contact, and also says the cameraman's confrontational language may weaken his position.

  • Charlotte County deputies question man openly carrying rifle while fishing

    November 1, 2022 · Charlotte County Sheriff's Office · Charlotte County, FL

    Deputies approached a man fishing with a rifle after a public complaint, according to the narrator. The fisherman asked what reasonable articulable suspicion the deputies had, and a deputy asked whether he was a convicted felon and whether he was underage. The deputy agreed that open carry while fishing is not illegal in Florida and that a person must be legally able to possess a firearm. The fisherman declined to give his name, the deputy gave his name and badge number, and the encounter ended with the deputy saying 'dismissed' after a conversation about fish.

  • Boca Raton officer questions citizen in public building and declines to demand ID

    October 21, 2022 · Boca Raton Police Department · Boca Raton, FL

    The narrator states that on October 21, 2022, inside a public building in Boca Raton, Florida, an encounter captured by Injustice Wars centered on repeated police contact. The citizen says he is conducting lawful business and is not required to show ID. He tells the officer that the repeated police calls show racism by the city. The officer says he is responding because people have called and he suggests the citizen is not conducting business. When asked, the officer gives his name as Officer Step with badge number 678, and says the matter will go to the city attorney. The narrator grades the citizen B+ and the officer B minus for staying professional but not clearly explaining a legal basis.

  • Punta Gorda officers cite bullhorn ordinance and request ID from protester

    July 1, 2022 · Punta Gorda Police Department · Punta Gorda, FL

    The narrator states that in July 2022 police confronted a protester using a bullhorn over a city noise ordinance. Officers said the protester violated city code 14-2 and could use a sign but not the bullhorn. The protester asked whether the matter was civil or criminal, was told it was civil, and refused to show ID until told what crime he committed. Officers said a repeat use would bring a $100 fine and possible arrest for obstruction. They told him to contest it before the code board. The protester called the ordinance unconstitutional and said it was selectively enforced.

  • Courthouse security order citizen out over phone and camera ban, then arrest him

    June 29, 2022 · Halifax County Sheriff's Office · Halifax County, VA

    The narrator states that on June 29, 2022 a citizen arrived at Halifax General District Court for a hearing while recording. He challenged a posted ban on phones and cameras and asked why a court employee could carry a phone. An officer said he was refusing to allow recording devices but could go to court without his phone. After repeated requests to leave, the citizen said he was a pro se litigant and had a right to record, and officers threatened a disorderly conduct charge. He said officers put hands on him and pushed him toward the exit. Near the end an officer told him to turn around and put his hands behind his back, and he asked what he was being arrested for.

  • Sullivan County deputies issue trespass notice to man seeking public records

    June 2, 2022 · Sullivan County Sheriff's Office · Sullivan County, TN

    A man went to the Sullivan County Sheriff's Office in Tennessee to make a public records request. Deputies asked him to step outside and told him he was banned from the property, with criminal trespass if he returned. They cited prior cursing and swearing in front of records staff. The man said he was being banned for protected speech, and the deputies cited an attorney general opinion and case law about harassing employees. The deputies said records requests could be mailed in. The man disputed this, and he also criticized the department over a separate complaint involving a jailer.

  • Manchester officers stop driver minutes after he criticized them for blocking roadway

    May 19, 2022 · Manchester Police Department · Manchester, NH

    The narrator states that on May 19, 2022 in Manchester, New Hampshire, a driver called out officers for blocking a roadway, drove away, and was pulled over minutes later. Officers said they saw a lane stoppage and that the driver's turn signal did not register on the car. The driver said he used his signal and called the stop retaliation, noting that several officers surrounded the vehicle. An officer is heard giving the name "katano" when asked for name and badge number. The video's narrator says the officers cited traffic grounds but that the timing and escalation raised questions.

  • Police demand ID and threaten arrest after trespass warning at Idaho post office

    July 2, 2021 · Kootenai County Sheriff's Office · Kootenai County, ID

    According to the narrator, the encounter was recorded on July 2, 2021 in Kootenai County, Idaho (captioned as Coupney or Quinney County). An auditor filming in a postal facility was questioned by employees about his identity and photography. Postal staff said he could take pictures but asked him to back away from customers. A regional supervisor and later a responding officer told him he was being trespassed from the property. When he said he would show ID only under threat of arrest, an officer replied that he would be arrested if he did not show ID and leave the property. Officers were also asked for names and badge numbers, and one replied that they did not have badge numbers.

  • Library staff call police over filming; officers review policy and leave auditor alone

    May 5, 2021 · Southampton Town Police Department · Southampton Town, NY

    The narrator states that on May 5, 2021, a First Amendment auditor entered Rogers Memorial Library in Southampton, New York. Staff asked for his name for occupancy tracking, and he declined to give a real name. After he began filming, the library director said staff and patrons could not be recorded without permission and called police. Officers asked him why he was filming. One officer briefly asked him to stay while they worked out the policy. The auditor asked whether he was detained, and a sergeant later reviewed the library policy. The auditor left without any stated arrest or citation.

  • Manchester officers respond to UPS Customer Center call about auditor filming

    January 21, 2021 · Manchester Police Department · Manchester, NH

    The narrator states that on January 21, 2021 a First Amendment audit outside the UPS Customer Center in Manchester, New Hampshire led to a police response after employees objected to filming. A UPS representative is heard saying filming is not a crime in itself but company policy is to investigate. The auditor says he is documenting UPS. Manchester police arrive and the auditor asks officers for names and badge numbers; one is heard giving a name like Peters, badge 88, and another giving shield 144. The auditor asks if he is detained and is told no. He refuses to answer questions, and an officer asks him to keep his hand out of his pocket. The officers say they will talk to the caller. The narrator cites Glik v. Cunniffe and grades the police B minus and the citizen B.

  • Tulsa officer threatens trespass citation over sidewalk boundary near Planned Parenthood

    December 5, 2020 · Tulsa Police Department · Tulsa, OK

    The narrator states that on December 5, 2020 in Tulsa, a citizen filming near a Planned Parenthood property was threatened with a trespass citation after not immediately handing over ID. The citizen repeatedly asked the first officer where a pedestrian could lawfully walk where the sidewalk ends, and the officer said the citizen was on the property owner's land and demanded a driver's license. The citizen said he would show his license to the supervisor. When the supervisor arrived, he said he would have to see the legal description and then marked an easement line and said the citizen could stay where he was without blocking the alley or parking lot. The narrator rates the first officer lower and the supervisor higher.

  • Manchester officers detain man filming police lot, ID refusal

    August 7, 2020 · Manchester Police Department · Manchester, NH

    The narrator states that on August 7, 2020, a man returned to film outside the Manchester Police Department in New Hampshire after claiming he had been identified and detained during an earlier audit. Several officers approached and asked why he was filming a secure lot and requested identification. The man said he had committed no crime, stated that New Hampshire is not a stop-and-identify state, and declined to give his ID or first name. An officer told him he was being detained, and he asked for a supervisor and for the specific crime or statute, with the officer replying 'Not at the moment.' The man said he would walk away if no crime could be articulated, and the clip does not show the outcome.

  • Clark County Sheriff's Office staff decline to take citizen's complaints

    August 1, 2020 · Clark County Sheriff's Office · Clark County, IN

    The narrator states that in August 2020, inside the Clark County Sheriff's Office in Jeffersonville, Indiana, a citizen tried to file complaints against officers. A captain and a colonel spoke with him. The citizen said an officer was rude to him, and the colonel said the citizen was also rude in the video. In a later visit, the colonel said the complaint about one officer was unfounded. When the citizen tried to file complaints against several other officers, he was told he had no business there and had to leave. The citizen said he had business there and asked for the sheriff, who was said to be unavailable.

  • Tampa officer opens and removes unattended bag in park; auditors object

    July 1, 2020 · Tampa Police Department · Tampa, FL

    The narrator states that in July 2020 a citizen journalist in Tampa, Florida, saw an officer examine and remove a bag of clothing left in a public park. The auditors said the officer opened the bag and went through it, and argued this violated the owner's Fourth Amendment rights. The officer was said to plan to put it in Tampa police property or lost and found, and the auditors said the owner would have to sign a release to retrieve it. The auditors asked for the officer's name and badge number and said they would file an internal affairs complaint. The narrator grades the citizen B+ and the officer C+ and describes a possible community caretaking function.

  • Marion, Texas speeding stop where driver declines questions

    March 9, 2020 · Marion Police Department · Marion, TX

    The driver says he was stopped on FM 78 near Marion, Texas, for allegedly doing 54 in a 35. He handed his license through a barely opened window and said he refused to answer questions. He livestreamed while waiting about 15 to 20 minutes and said the officer waited for backup before issuing the citation. A sheriff and another person arrived, and the officer then issued a citation for 54 in a 35. The officer thanked the driver for his cooperation and gave him a copy of the citation.

  • Wayland police staff handle broad public records request and show identification on request

    September 1, 2019 · Wayland Police Department · Wayland, MA

    The narrator states that on September 1, 2019, a citizen entered the Wayland Police Department with a long public records request. The request covered marijuana arrests, dispatch audio, internal emails, destruction procedures, patrol vehicle mileage and traffic ticket totals. Department staff asked clarifying questions and offered to provide citation totals. The citizen also asked about a separate emailed records request, which staff said had been moved to the town administrator's office. When asked, the staff member agreed to show his police identification card. The narrator describes staff as cooperative and responsive and grades the department A minus.

  • Mendota officers detain photographer filming nursing home from sidewalk

    July 1, 2019 · Mendota Police Department · Mendota, IL

    According to the narrator, in July 2019 a photographer on a public sidewalk outside a nursing home in Mendota, Illinois was approached by an officer who said she was getting complaints about the filming. The officer ordered him to stop, cited disorderly conduct, said she would handcuff him, and said she was detaining him until she learned what he was doing. A sergeant arrived, and the officers said they were investigating a report that he was videotaping residents inside. The man repeatedly asked what crime he was suspected of, said he was only filming from the sidewalk, and declined to answer questions. The narrator says officers struggled to name a specific crime and grades the police articulation of reasonable suspicion a D.

  • Salem officers investigate man in parked car while auditor films and requests ID

    June 1, 2019 · Salem Police Department · Salem, MA

    The narrator states that in June 2019 a First Amendment auditor documented Salem police investigating a man reportedly found slumped in a vehicle. The auditor questioned why the man was given a field sobriety test and repeatedly asked an officer for his name and badge number. The auditor identified the officer as "Reagan" and said the officer did not give his name or badge number. Later a sergeant on scene gave a name and the number 163 when asked, and the auditor called this professional. The narrator notes Massachusetts statutes on officer identification and case law on the right to record, and says officers can still control distance and movement.

  • Pueblo officers recognize auditor and end encounter cordially

    April 1, 2019 · Pueblo Police Department · Pueblo, CO

    The narrator says that in April 2019, body camera footage from Pueblo, Colorado showed officers responding to a reported neighborhood confrontation. The scene shifted to a discussion about filming. The auditor said he was relieved to be out of handcuffs, and an officer chatted with him about camera equipment and told him how to request body camera video through a records request, which carries a fee. An officer told the auditor he could leave. An officer said an off-duty officer had called in the encounter and that he had known about the auditor beforehand. The narrator grades the police de-escalation and professionalism B+.

  • Peoria Park District officers and copwatcher discuss filming after public drinking citation

    March 1, 2019 · Peoria Park District · Peoria County, IL

    The narrator states that in March 2019 at Bradley Park in Peoria, Illinois, officers cited a man for public drinking while a citizen followed and recorded. The officers asked why he was following and recording them. The officers said they worry about safety during stops and that a third watcher adds to their attention. The citizen said he stays in view and keeps his distance, and he cited First Amendment protection. The talk ended cordially. The citizen gave his channel name and the officers introduced themselves.

  • Miami man filming near police scene is taken to the ground and arrested

    February 12, 2019 · Miami Police Department · Miami, FL

    The narrator states that on February 12, 2019 in Miami, a man filming near an active police scene got into a heated exchange with multiple officers. Officers are heard saying they had set a perimeter, and the filmer repeatedly asks whether there is a shooter or danger. The filmer is heard telling an officer not to touch him, then shouting "I'm not resisting" and calling for help while being held. He is told he is under arrest, and he asks why he is being detained. The narrator says the key legal question is whether he crossed into a restricted area or was detained without clear probable cause.

  • Charlotte-Mecklenburg officers order open carry citizen to leave police headquarters parking area

    January 8, 2019 · Charlotte-Mecklenburg Police Department · Charlotte-Mecklenburg, NC

    The narrator states that on January 8, 2019, an armed citizen conducting an open carry audit was approached by officers outside Charlotte-Mecklenburg police headquarters. Officers said the property belongs to the city and is not open to the public in the sense the citizen claimed, and that he could be asked to leave or banned. The citizen repeatedly asked whether the lot was public and whether he was being threatened with arrest, and criticized an officer for keeping a hand on his holstered gun. Officers said that if he did not leave he would be subject to arrest for trespassing, and the citizen then left while objecting. The narrator grades the officers a C for not explaining the legal basis of the order.

  • Mount Dora officers question man filming police facility and ask about his mental state

    December 9, 2018 · Mount Dora Police Department · Mount Dora, FL

    The narrator states this occurred December 9, 2018 in Mount Dora, Florida, where a man silently recorded a police facility. Officers said it was odd to videotape a public safety compound, asked whether he understood them, asked for ID, asked for his Social Security number, and asked if he knew the current president. An officer said fire and EMS would come check him for medical issues and asked to pat him down for weapons. The man declined to give his Social Security number and asked whether he was being detained. The narrator says the escalation to mental health questions and a pat-down suggestion without clear reasonable suspicion may raise concerns.

  • Elbert County deputies approach and photograph auditors filming near justice center

    June 26, 2018 · Elbert County Sheriff's Office · Elbert County, CO

    The narrator states that on June 26, 2018, auditors filmed at the Elbert County Justice Center in Kiowa, Colorado. A sergeant who identified himself as Sergeant Turner of the Elbert County Sheriff's Office approached and asked whether they needed help and what they were filming. The auditors declined help. The deputy said he had the right to photograph them, and the auditors said they would file a records request for his photos. The auditors later said deputies appeared to be following them. The narrator says contact was brief and non-forceful and grades law enforcement B+.

  • Phoenix post office officers and postal staff tell auditors to stop filming and ask for ID

    June 13, 2018 · Phoenix Police Department · Phoenix, AZ

    The narrator states this occurred June 13, 2018 in Phoenix, Arizona, at a post office. An officer said he was on patrol, did not claim to know everything, and relayed that the superintendent did not want filming on site. A second speaker said he consulted a legal unit and said the post office lobby is not a typical public forum, while the sidewalk is. The auditors cited Poster 7 and said the lobby is publicly accessible. The speaker then asked them to leave and asked for identification, saying it had moved to the criminal side and that they could be trespassed. The narrator says Poster 7 generally allows photography in lobbies and that asking for ID without clear trespass or refusal may be premature.

  • Pueblo County deputies question masked person filming sheriff's office

    October 28, 2017 · Pueblo County Sheriff's Office · Pueblo County, CO

    The narrator states an auditor was recording from a public area outside the Pueblo County Sheriff's Office in Pueblo West, Colorado, on October 28, 2017. Deputies said they were responding to callers reporting suspicious behavior and asked why the person was masked and filming. They asked him to lift his shirt and turn around, and later asked for his name. The auditor repeatedly asked whether he was detained, and deputies said he was not. He declined to identify himself or lift his shirt, citing Colorado law. A supervisor was requested but did not arrive, and the auditor left. He said the deputies were professional and courteous but that he still believed his rights were violated.

  • Photographer returns to Dallas substation to discuss prior encounter with supervisor

    June 6, 2017 · Dallas Police Department · Dallas, TX

    The citizen returned the next day (stated as June 6th, 2017) to a Dallas police substation to finish photographing the flag. He told a supervisor that five officers contacted him the day before. He said Officer Barker gave him incorrect information about photographing vehicles and license plates, and that another supervisor did not give a name or badge number. The supervisor listened, apologized for poor service, explained the department's concerns about attacks on police stations, and directed him to internal affairs at 14 South Lamar if he wanted to make a complaint. The citizen praised Officer Hunt and said Officer Barker likely needed more training.

  • Dallas officers question photographer of flag outside police facility

    June 4, 2017 · Dallas Police Department · Dallas, TX

    A citizen photographing an American flag from a public sidewalk outside a Dallas police facility was approached by officers. One officer said he was not allowed to photograph police cars and that a public area and a private area existed, and said he would be trespassing if he crossed into the private area. A second officer said photography from the sidewalk was fine, explained that officers were nervous because of ambushes on police, and said he would handle the matter. The citizen gave only his first name and declined to give his last name, and the officer said that was fine.

  • Middletown officers detain man filming police department as a "suspicious party" and ask for ID

    June 1, 2013 · Middletown Police Department · Middletown, CT

    The narrator states that in June 2013 outside the Middletown Police Department in Connecticut, a citizen recording government property was stopped and questioned. An officer identified as Peck, badge 7099, called him a suspicious party, said he was detained during an investigation, and repeatedly asked for ID. The officer said he was trying to determine why the man was filming the back area of the police department. The citizen refused and repeatedly asked what crime was suspected. The officer said he was not sure and was trying to determine it. The officer also said his hand was resting on his gun, and asked if the citizen had a medical condition because he appeared to be shaking. Other officers arrived, and one explained that about three weeks earlier someone had fired rounds at the back of another police department, which heightened awareness about the unsecured back lot. The citizen was then allowed to leave.

  • Clarendon Hills officers demand ID during disputed sign ordinance citation

    Clarendon Hills Police Department · Clarendon Hills, IL

    The narrator states that in February 2019 in Clarendon Hills, Illinois, a dispute over signs on a public sidewalk became an ID refusal confrontation. An officer said the citizen had been cited and needed to provide ID for the ticket, and said the citizen would otherwise be handcuffed. The citizens said the signs were not touching the village sign and asked which village ordinance applied. Officers cited "44 15" and offered to let the citizens tear up the ticket. A citizen said he would give his name and birthday but not an ID. The narrator gives the officer a C and the citizen a B+.

  • North Brunswick officers at doorway of home during 911 hang-up check

    North Brunswick Township Police Department · North Brunswick Township, NJ

    The narrator states that in September 2021 North Brunswick, New Jersey officers responded to a 911 hang-up call. The homeowner repeatedly ordered the officers out, said they had no warrant, and refused to give his name. Officers said they were confirming occupant safety, and one officer said they had traced the number to a landline. The homeowner claimed an officer hit him with the door and mentioned an existing internal affairs complaint. Officers eventually left after confirming no one needed assistance.

  • Beverly Hills officers respond after petitioner's camera equipment allegedly taken

    Beverly Hills Police Department · Beverly Hills, CA

    The video opens with a person objecting to being filmed, followed by a scene in which a petitioner/videographer says another man attacked him and took his equipment. Responding officers ask whether he is injured or needs medical treatment, view his video, and ask for ID. The petitioner says he wants to press charges and a police report filed. Officers tell him he can keep recording, and the narrator later says felony charges for the attack and theft of a monopod were being discussed. Officers are shown being cordial; one says he has 20 years on the job and another says four or five months.

  • Bowling Green officer asks auditor about City Hall complaint, acknowledges he cannot stop filming

    Bowling Green Police Department · Bowling Green, KY

    An officer, heard as Gerber or Garber, approached an auditor after a call about him filming at Bowling Green City Hall. The officer asked whether anyone had told him to leave or stop filming. The auditor declined to give his name, saying he had not committed a crime, and the officer did not press the point. The officer said he could not stop him from filming and described it as First Amendment protected activity. He offered a paper with the incident number, and the auditor was told to file an open records request with the police department. The narrator's commentary says the officer respected the ID refusal.

  • Norman officer responds to complaint about filming outside dispensary

    Norman Police Department · Norman, OK

    Auditors film from the public sidewalk outside a dispensary and talk with staff. A manager says he does not want filming of the building or patients and asks them to leave or he will call police. An officer arrives and tells them they are on a public sidewalk. He says they should not step into the parking lot, which he said would be trespassing, and that people have complained they were uncomfortable. He gives his badge number and a CAD number. The auditors accuse him of sexual harassment toward another officer and he says they are free to do as they wish.

  • North Chicago FOIA follow-up on earlier recording dispute yields written response

    North Chicago Police Department · North Chicago, IL

    An auditor followed up on a public records request about an earlier dispute over recording at a public facility. He spoke with a Lieutenant Martin about a delay of about a month, although he said state law sets a five-day deadline. The lieutenant said he made an initial inquiry and passed a recommendation to the chief. A written response from the lieutenant then arrived. As read aloud in the video, it says officers were dispatched to the Lake County Health Department for an unwanted subject. It says they determined that recording in a public facility is within a citizen's First Amendment rights, and that no NCPD policy, Chicago Police Department policy or criminal law was violated. The narrator says the auditor's cover-up claims remain allegations.

  • Costa Mesa officer questions Canadian driver's license during traffic stop

    Costa Mesa Police Department · Costa Mesa, CA

    A driver who says he is a Canadian tourist was stopped, and an officer told him a records check showed no California license was ever issued to him. The driver said he held a Canadian license and had given proof of insurance, and the two disputed whether the insurance document had been provided. The officer asked about license class, physical description and vehicle registration, and later asked for a passport. The officer said a visitor has 10 days for the license to be valid, and the driver disagreed. The narrator states the officer cited impeding traffic, although the officer's exchange at the end sounds cordial. The narrator cites California Vehicle Code 12502 as generally allowing a nonresident adult to drive on a valid foreign license.

  • Deputies decline to take criminal report about towed RV and argue it is civil

    Halifax County Sheriff's Office · Halifax County, VA

    A citizen asked deputies to take a criminal report about his RV, which he described as his primary residence, being towed. He said the removal was a felony and asked for a supervisor. A deputy said the matter was civil, and he said he had never been told he was trespassing. A deputy said the town's South Boston Police Department towed the vehicle and that a report number would exist if the county had been involved. The citizen cited several federal statutes, said the deputies were committing misprision of a felony, and said he objected to being recorded. The narrator states that the dispute centers on whether the matter is theft or a civil towing issue.

  • San Antonio officers hold man's ID while verifying age of adult companion

    San Antonio Police Department · San Antonio, TX

    In San Antonio, Texas, a man sitting in his truck says officers approached and asked questions. He handed over his ID card and says an officer then kept it. The man and his 18-year-old companion repeatedly asked whether they were detained and what crime was suspected. An officer said he was verifying the companion's information and wanted to call her mother. The man called 911 and said he was being unlawfully detained, and the companion showed a birth certificate. An officer said it is against the law not to have a Texas ID, and the man disputed this. The officers wrote an information report, said they could follow up with a complaint, and told them they were free to go.

  • Santa Rosa County deputies and K9 search of friend's vehicle; filmer disputes 25-foot rule

    Santa Rosa County Sheriff's Office · Santa Rosa County, FL

    The narrator says a driver was pulled over a second time and a K9 was called. A bystander who says he is the driver's friend and lives in the county confronts deputies, asks for names and badge numbers, and disputes how close he may stand under the 25-foot law. Deputies tell him the stop is over and he is free to leave. A deputy later talks with the filmer, saying he is not sure whether the 25 feet is measured from the detained vehicle or from patrol vehicles and that he will take the question to general counsel. The filmer questions the dog alert, saying marijuana is not a narcotic and the dog does not alert to it. The deputy suggests residual odor may explain the alert, and the filmer says he will request records.

  • La Pryor deputy and driver dispute window tint and questions during traffic stop

    Zavala County Sheriff's Office · Zavala County, TX

    The narrator states that in September 2023 in La Pryor, Texas, a deputy stopped a driver for speeding. The driver provided a license and insurance but declined to answer further questions or roll up a tinted window, saying he would comply with lawful orders but did not have to assist the investigation. The deputy said he could remove the driver from the vehicle for officer safety and referred to a window tint violation, and the two disagreed over reasonable suspicion versus probable cause. The deputy asked repeatedly for height and for the license to be displayed again, and ultimately issued a citation. Both the deputy and the driver used profanity toward each other near the end.

  • Park City officers enter home and use Taser on father after he ends conversation

    Park City Police Department · Park City, UT

    Officers went to a home in response to a neighborhood dispute involving a teenager, his father, and a report that a firearm was involved. The narrator states the father declined to discuss the incident and tried to end the conversation, and that officers then forced their way into the home. The narrator says an officer used a Taser during the arrest, while the teenage son recorded from the staircase and then followed officers outside. Officers told the son to give them space and said they did not need a search warrant, and the family said no gun was involved. The video states the narrator's later account (policy violations, dismissals, a 42 U.S.C. 1983 lawsuit) comes from the original report and does not show it in the footage.

  • Jackson Township auditor discusses police station access and Daniel's Law with officer

    Jackson Township Police Department · Jackson Township, NJ

    The narrator states this occurred in October 2024 in Jackson Township, New Jersey, when a public filmer returned to a police facility after receiving a trespassing summons. In a long conversation with an officer, the filmer said he would not publish officers' home addresses and referenced Daniel's Law. The officer said the filmer was trying to circumvent privacy protections, and the filmer said license plate information is available through apps. The filmer also said that some officers were improperly engaged in misconduct and described a prior complaint. Both sides said a judge would ultimately decide the matter, and the filmer acknowledged he could not enter the parking lot area marked by signs.

  • Lake County officers issue trespass warning to man making public records request at elementary school

    Lake County Sheriff's Office · Lake County, FL

    A man filming outside an elementary school in Lake County, Florida, says he is there to make a public records request under Florida Chapter 119. Officers and school staff tell him he cannot enter without showing ID and that the principal does not want him there. The man repeatedly asks whether he is detained and is told at times that he is free to go. One officer tells him to take his hands out of his pockets, and the man calls this a detention. A trespass warning is later arranged at the principal's request, and officers repeatedly ask for his ID or name to complete the form. He declines and says he knows of no statute requiring it. An officer says the trespass warning is good for one year.

  • Florence County deputies respond after auditor reports contractor employee grabbed his camera

    Florence County Sheriff's Office · Florence County, SC

    The narrator states that an employee of a company approached an auditor photographing from outside private property, demanded he stop filming, and attempted to seize his camera. Both men went inside and contacted the Florence County Sheriff's Office, and deputies arrived about 20 minutes later. The auditor told deputies he had been assaulted and wanted to press charges, and the employee said he pulled out a Taser in self defense. A deputy gave the auditor an ID and phone number questions to take a report, and a supervisor told the auditor that yelling across the parking lot was a breach of peace, saying he would lock him up. The auditor challenged this and said he had a right to speak. He then gave his email address for the report.

  • Burlington police respond to journalists' citizen's arrest claim at federal building

    Burlington Police Department · Burlington, VT

    Two people who described themselves as independent journalists called Burlington police to a federal courthouse and post office. They said a courthouse security officer physically pushed one of them out while they were filming, and that they had placed him under citizen's arrest for assault. The responding officer said he would not arrest anyone before an investigation, and asked for identification and the purpose of their visit. The journalists declined, saying they did not have to answer questions. They were told the building was closed and that they must leave, and they asked for a written trespass notice. Tension rose before the officer's supervisor was requested.

  • Haverhill officers obtain passenger's name during traffic stop and are questioned by auditors

    Haverhill Police Department · Haverhill, MA

    After a traffic stop, auditors observe officers obtaining a passenger's identification or name. They confront the officers, saying police need reasonable articulable suspicion to ask a passenger for ID. An officer says the Supreme Court has ruled that officers are allowed to ask. The auditors say the passenger did not know his rights and gave his ID. The officer says the passenger gave it voluntarily, and the discussion becomes heated. An officer gives his name and badge number on request. The narrator's closing analysis says asking is not necessarily a violation but compelling ID normally needs a legal basis.

  • Pueblo County deputies ask auditor for ID and waistband check after suspicious person call

    Pueblo County Sheriff's Office · Pueblo County, CO

    The narrator states that in December 2020 in Pueblo County, Colorado, a First Amendment auditor was recording outside a sheriff's office when officers approached after suspicious person calls. Deputies asked him to lift his shirt and show his waistband and asked for his name. The auditor repeatedly asked whether he was detained, and the deputy said he was not being detained. The auditor said Colorado is not a stop-and-identify state. A deputy said that anytime they contact someone, the person needs to identify themselves. The auditor asked for a supervisor and declined to identify himself or lift his shirt. The narrator rates the officers as remaining professional while some legal claims were disputed.

  • Oro Valley police detain man filming at Public Works office

    Oro Valley Police Department · Oro Valley, AZ

    Oro Valley police officers responded to a call from Public Works employees describing a visitor as combative. On arrival, officers told the man, who was recording, that he was detained for investigation and not free to leave. He repeatedly asked what crime he was suspected of; the officers did not name one on camera, said they were investigating the call, and one officer warned he could be charged with disorderly conduct if he did not lower his voice.

  • NYPD officers cite department policy when auditor films inside police facility

    New York City Police Department · New York City, NY

    An auditor filming at a police facility asks officers to cite a law that prohibits recording in a public building. Officers say it is department policy and that they were instructed to refer the matter to their legal department. The auditor repeatedly says officers enforce laws, not policy, and asks them to identify themselves and provide a complaint form. Several additional officers arrive, and one officer says he is trying to be professional and offers a business card. The narrator says the debate centers on whether an internal policy can restrict a constitutional activity.

  • High Point post office auditor ordered to leave under trespass warning

    High Point Police Department · High Point, NC

    At a postal facility in High Point, North Carolina, an auditor and others argue with officers and staff about filming inside. The auditor cites USPS Poster 7 and asks to speak to the postmaster and for officers' names and badge numbers. An officer says the auditor will be told to leave and not return, and that he will be arrested for trespassing if he does not leave. The auditor says they will leave under threat of arrest and says his rights were violated. An officer is heard giving the name Martin as the group leaves.

  • Bossier City supervisors order reasonable-suspicion drug test of off-duty officer after 911 report

    Bossier City Police Department · Bossier City, LA

    According to the description, a 911 caller reported a marked Bossier City Police vehicle swerving into oncoming traffic in Benton, Louisiana. The off-duty officer, heard as Coker, says he dropped his phone and was tired, and that he was not driving when supervisors arrived. A captain and a sergeant order him to go for reasonable-suspicion testing immediately. He repeatedly says he cannot go at that moment because of family obligations and asks for time or a ride. Supervisors treat this as a refusal and say he will be placed on administrative leave. He also asks to retrieve personal items from the city vehicle, which they do not allow until inventory is finished.

  • Library security guard threatens pepper spray during filming dispute in Las Cruces

    Las Cruces Police Department · Las Cruces, NM

    The narrator says a First Amendment audit at the Las Cruces Public Library escalated into a confrontation over a camera and a library filming policy. A library staff member read a policy on filming and asked the auditor to stop, saying a supervisor had said filming was not allowed. The auditor replied that policy is not law and refused to stop. A security guard said he had the right to detain the auditor, and the auditor said the guard was going to pepper spray him. Staff said they would call police, and the auditor said two officers were arriving. The transcript does not show the outcome.

  • Tumwater police respond to records request and filming dispute at state printing office

    Tumwater Police Department · Tumwater, WA

    According to the description, an auditor requested public records at Washington DES Printing and Imaging in Tumwater and filmed customer pick-up logs visible in the lobby. Employees told him to leave and called police, and one said the staff felt intimidated. Officer Hammond told him the property representatives wanted him gone and gave an oral trespass warning. The auditor declined to give his name and asked the officer to consult the city attorney first. A second officer said staff had given him the form and that he would be taken to jail for trespassing if he did not leave.

  • Pennsville officers ask parked driver for ID during suspicious vehicle call

    Pennsville Township Police Department · Pennsville Township, NJ

    Officers responded to a report of a suspicious vehicle parked in front of a house and asked the driver for his name, license, and registration. The driver, who was recorded by his own camera, asked whether he was suspected of a crime, invoked his Fifth Amendment right to remain silent, and declined to provide documents. An officer said the encounter was a suspicious person/vehicle investigation and that there was no crime established so far, and told the driver he was still detained. The officers later proposed running the license plate to check the registered owner against a DMV photo, and the driver agreed. An officer said police were in the area because of an incident at a school about 100 yards away, and the driver was told he could leave.

  • Olmos Park citizens deliver petition and citizen's arrest warning to police department

    Olmos Park Police Department · Olmos Park, TX

    A group of citizens gathered outside the Olmos Park, Texas police department, which the narrator says was after accusing local officers of violating constitutional rights in earlier encounters. No officers came out, so they taped a petition to the front door. A speaker, who said he was the author, read a notice addressed to the police chief, spoken as "Renee Valenciano". He cited the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure on citizen's arrest and 18 USC 242. The notice said the group would arrest an officer they personally witnessed violating constitutional rights while using or threatening to use a dangerous weapon. It said the group would hand that officer to federal authorities. The speaker stated this was not a threat of violence. No police officers appear on camera.

  • Pasco officers respond to business owner complaint about auditors filming nearby

    Pasco Police Department · Pasco, WA

    Auditors who had been at a car business the day before returned, and the owner called police. The owner's complaint was that they had bothered a customer and were on his property, which the auditors denied. Responding officers, including one who gave his name as Santiago, badge 154, and a sergeant, spoke with the auditors and asked about the effect on the business. The auditors said they had not entered the property and called the report false. The officers said the owner knew their rights and was concerned about his business, and the encounter ended with no enforcement action and a friendly tone.

  • McDowell County deputies ask photographer to leave sheriff's office lot and pat him down

    McDowell County Sheriff's Office · Mcdowell County, NC

    A man photographing vehicles at the McDowell County Sheriff's Department was approached by several officers who asked for his ID and his reason for taking pictures. He said he was on public property, had committed no crime, and declined to give his name. Officers said some vehicles were undercover, that the site includes a detention facility, and that he could be charged with trespassing if he did not leave. An officer asked about weapons and patted him down with his consent, saying it was for their safety. The man said he would leave, and he asked for officers' names and the chief deputy's name.

  • Police check on auditor filming from sidewalk outside Starbucks after staff complaints

    Edmond Police Department · Edmond, OK

    The narrator states that in April 2026 an auditor was filming the drive-through and license plates outside a Starbucks in Edmond, Oklahoma. Staff said customers were uncomfortable and told him they were asked by a manager to have him leave or call police. An officer arrived, gave his name and badge number as heard, and spoke with the auditor, who said he was on the sidewalk recording peacefully. The officer said he would tell the staff the auditor was not doing anything wrong. The encounter ended cordially.

  • Huntington Beach traffic stop with repeated requests for driver's address and personal details

    Huntington Beach Police Department · Huntington Beach, CA

    The narrator states this is a traffic stop in Huntington Beach, California, recorded in June 2026. The driver repeatedly asks the officer to write the ticket while the officer asks for his address, zip code, license number, date of birth, height and weight. The officer is heard saying the driver is getting close to going to jail and that questions must be answered, and the driver says he is answering everything and objects to the officer's attitude. The driver eventually provides the information, receives the citation, and the stop ends with thanks from the driver. The narrator later describes the interaction as becoming unnecessarily confrontational after the citation was completed.

  • North Chicago officers respond to health department over recording and FOIA request

    North Chicago Police Department · North Chicago, IL

    Staff at the health department object to a citizen who says he is an independent journalist recording in the lobby and seeking a FOIA form. A sergeant and other officers respond. The sergeant says the building is a medical facility with sensitive information and asks the citizen to stop recording. The citizen says he is in a publicly accessible area and that policy is not law, and he asks whether he is being ordered to stop. The citizen asks the officers to get the names of staff for his FOIA form, and they decline. The narrator questions whether the restriction was valid.

  • Airway Heights officers ask journalist to sign in at water reclamation plant

    Airway Heights Police Department · Airway Heights, WA

    Officers responded to a call from a water reclamation facility about a visitor who had not signed in. They told the journalist that facility staff wanted visitors to sign in, that a sign on the main door required it, and that staff did not want him removed. The journalist said he was working on an ecology story and was concerned about using a pen name on the sign-in. An officer went to speak with facility staff and returned saying staff were fine with him signing in and would give him a tour. Officers stayed conversational, did not demand ID, and provided a case number on request. The narrator describes the officers as professional and de-escalating.

  • Boca Raton officers approach person recording in public library after staff request

    Boca Raton Police Department · Boca Raton, FL

    The narrator states that at the Boca Raton Public Library in Florida, police approached a citizen who was recording inside the building after library staff asked for assistance. The citizen said he had spoken with the city attorney that morning. He repeatedly asked whether he had committed a crime and asked the officers to call their sergeant. An officer said they wanted to deliver library rules, and the citizen asked whether he was being excluded from the library. Officers did not clearly state a crime in the portion heard. They then told him they would leave him alone, followed or escorted him out of the library, and gave their names as heard.

  • Peterborough officer asks for ID during call about filming at manufacturer

    Peterborough Police Department · Peterborough, NH

    A cameraman filming from what he calls public property outside New Hampshire Ball Bearings was approached by company staff, and an HR employee said police were being called. An officer arrived, and the cameraman asked for his name and badge number, which he gave as Stone, 95. The officer asked for identification and date of birth, and the cameraman declined. When the cameraman asked if he was being detained, the officer said no, and when asked if he had to give ID, the officer said he would like to see it. The narrator adds commentary citing NH RSA 594:2 and says the citizen was not detained and could decline voluntary questions.

  • Clark Public Utilities security and deputies trespass man who refused ID and left lobby

    Clark County Sheriff's Office · Clark County, WA

    A security officer at Clark Public Utilities asked a man recording inside the building for ID and told him to come to the front, saying he had walked to the back and tried to open office doors. The man declined to provide ID or follow the security officer, and said he was there in connection with a public records request. Staff said the building was private property, while the man said it was a public utility run by an elected board. Deputies arrived and told him to leave or be arrested for trespass, and a no trespass notice was prepared. The man declined to give a name for the notice, and a deputy said the statute did not require ID.

  • Irvine officers repeatedly approach and question photographer outside police station

    Irvine Police Department · Irvine, CA

    The narrator states that in October 2018 outside the Irvine Police Department in Orange County, California, a citizen journalist recorded in public and several officers approached him. Officers repeatedly asked how they could help and why he was there, and said they had seen him on video near a gate. The photographer said he was not breaking the law and declined to answer questions. Officers said they never claimed he broke the law, and said they could talk to him. An officer gave his name and badge as heard, and at the end the photographer asked for complaint forms. The officers said the city, not they, held the forms and that a supervisor would handle it.

  • Jonesboro officer threatens detention over ID refusal during bank-area filming call

    Jonesboro Police Department · Jonesboro, AR

    An officer responds to a bank call about a man filming from the sidewalk. He asks the man for ID, and when the man declines and cites Florida v. J.L., the officer says 'I will detain you' if he does not provide it. The officer then speaks with bank staff, who say the man filmed the building, employees and vehicles. The bank manager's husband tells the officer he grabbed the man's camera pole and got in his face, but says he did not touch the man. The officer calls a supervisor and says the misdemeanor did not occur in his presence. He also says the man may film from the public sidewalk and does not have to identify himself for trespass if he was not on the property. No arrest is shown.

  • Myrtle Beach City Hall auditors told to leave public foyer or face arrest

    Myrtle Beach Police Department · Myrtle Beach, SC

    Auditors filming in a publicly accessible area of Myrtle Beach City Hall were questioned by police after employees asked them to leave. Officers asked for identification, citing a city ordinance and trespass after notice, and said ID was needed to enter them into the CAD system for a trespass warning. The auditors repeatedly asked what crime they had committed and asserted their First Amendment and Fourth Amendment rights. Officers said filming itself is not illegal, but that the group had been asked to leave. One auditor asked if they were being threatened with arrest if they did not leave, and an officer answered yes. The auditors then said they would leave under threat of arrest.

  • Santa Ana auditor requests corporal's name and badge, then files complaint

    Santa Ana Police Department · Santa Ana, CA

    An auditor asked a supervisor for his name and badge number. The auditor said officers are supposed to identify when asked, and noted the name tag was hard to read and needed polishing. The auditor said the supervisor did not identify himself, and the officer said he was not making an enforcement action. The auditor then went to the police department to file a complaint. There, an officer gave the name Garcia and a badge number, and the auditor identified the unit as 854. The auditor named the corporal as Nolan, asked for video, and had the date and time recorded.

  • Senatobia officers request ID from recorder outside restaurant after trespass request

    Senatobia Police Department · Senatobia, MS

    A restaurant owner (per the transcript) approaches a man recording outside and says staff, customers and minor employees are uncomfortable with the recording, then asks if he is almost done. The recorder says he will stay a couple more hours. An officer later says the manager is trespassing him from the property and asks for ID to fill out paperwork. The recorder states he has never been on the property and says ID is not required for simple trespass. The officer says he is being trespassed, and the segment ends without a stated arrest.

  • Pueblo officers handcuff man photographing police department

    Pueblo Police Department · Pueblo, CO

    A man photographing the Pueblo Police Department is approached by an officer who asks who he is and why he is taking pictures. The man says he is being put in handcuffs for taking pictures of a police department and asks for a supervisor. He states he does not consent to searches and cites a statute number, and he asks what crime gives reasonable suspicion. An officer tells him he is being detained while waiting for a supervisor. The man says he chose not to answer questions and livestreams a request to call the department. The officer's remarks include a profanity directed at him. The transcript does not show how the detention ended.

  • Bellwood police respond to bank security call about man photographing building from sidewalk

    Bellwood Police Department · Bellwood, IL

    A man filming Providence Bank from a public sidewalk in Bellwood, Illinois, was confronted by a bank security guard who said he was not allowed to photograph the bank. The security guard called police, and the auditor said the guard described him to dispatch as obnoxious. Bellwood officers arrived with lights and sirens. One officer told the auditor that he could record from a public space and that the bank had the right to feel unsafe on private property. An officer said the bank manager wanted to make a report. The auditor complained about the lights and sirens and the dispatch description, and asked for names, badge numbers and a call for service number, which an officer gave.

  • Romeoville officers respond to post office dispute over auditor recording

    Romeoville Police Department · Romeoville, IL

    A First Amendment auditor recorded inside a post office in Romeoville, Illinois. A customer objected, photographed him, and said she would call police. The auditor said he would photograph her license plate, and she objected to that. Several officers arrived, and the auditor says one told the customers that he had a right to record. The officers asked him for space and questioned his intentions, and the auditor stayed to film. The officers left without making an arrest, and the narrator says they avoided unnecessary escalation.

  • Trinidad officers order man recording near domestic violence response to leave

    Trinidad Police Department · Trinidad, CO

    In Trinidad, Colorado (per the description), officers confront a man recording police, firefighters and an ambulance near a reported domestic violence response. An officer tells the man he was told to stop filming the victim. The man denies filming the victim and offers to show his video. He asks repeatedly whether he is detained and asks what law he is breaking. An officer says a victims' rights act applies but, per the transcript, declines to give the statute. Near the end an officer says he is not being detained. The man is told to leave and says he is leaving.

  • Kent police respond to armory after captain's reported threat call about photographer

    Kent Police Department · Kent, WA

    A man filming outside an armory was confronted by a military captain who, per the transcript, claimed to be in charge and said the man was being detained for failure to disclose identity. Police then arrived and said they had received a call about a man making threats inside the establishment. The auditor said he had continuous video showing he never entered the property or made a threat, and he cited a Washington false reporting statute (as heard, RCW 9A.84.040). The officers did not arrest him, said a caller had reported him inside, and cautioned that he could be trespassed if he went inside. The auditor thanked the officers for their professionalism at the end.

  • Red Bank officers detain pedestrian over alleged signal violation and request ID

    Red Bank Police Department · Red Bank, NJ

    An officer accuses a citizen who was filming of crossing against a signal, and the citizen says he has video showing the light was green. The officer says the citizen is detained for a Title 39 violation and that he needs the citizen's name and date of birth to issue a summons. The citizen declines to identify himself, asks whether he will be arrested, and repeatedly asks for a supervisor. The officer says he could be arrested for trespassing, then says he did not say he would arrest him. A sergeant later speaks with the officers and the citizen is given a warning and told he is dismissed without giving ID.

  • San Jose officers discuss filming outside police building and interference with a caller

    San Jose Police Department · San Jose, CA

    An auditor filming outside a public building across from a police station is approached by officers who say they received calls about him. One officer says filming is legal but some people find it creepy, and another asks if he needs anything. The auditor says a man drove up to him and he began filming in response. An officer says he may film but should not interfere with someone talking to police, as this might be a criminal matter. The auditor asks what the offense would be, and an officer says something like 'that's 148' and he replies 'write me up for it, I'll see you in court'.

  • Manchester officers and auditor dispute distance during traffic stop outside public building

    Manchester Police Department · Manchester, NH

    The narrator states that in December 2022 a First Amendment auditor questioned why several police units surrounded a single driver during a traffic stop outside a public building in Manchester, New Hampshire. The auditor is heard telling officers to conduct their stop, and an officer is heard saying the auditor cannot talk to the detained driver because he is being detained on a police matter. An officer tells the auditor he may videotape but asks him to stand back or move out of the roadway, and the auditor says he is on the sidewalk. The auditor is heard saying he was asked to identify himself and detained without an articulated crime, then says he will walk away. The narrator's commentary says officers may set safety boundaries at a traffic stop, and grades the police C+ and the citizen B.

  • LMPD supervisor responds to citizen complaint about officer during recording incident

    Louisville Metro Police Department · Louisville Metro, KY

    The narrator states that in August 2025 in Louisville, Kentucky, a citizen confronted a Louisville Metro Police Department (LMPD) supervisor after claiming an officer ignored policy during a First Amendment recording incident. The supervisor asked for the citizen's information to send video by email and described options: handling the matter informally through counseling or training, or filing a sworn formal complaint with the Public Standards Unit (PSU) at First and Liberty. The citizen said the officer put hands on a member of the public and did not notify a supervisor as policy requires, and asked the supervisor to remind the officer of his demeanor. The supervisor said he could not impose formal discipline and offered to call the citizen with a follow up after the informal review.

  • Plant 42 security guards question photographer on public easement

    Los Angeles County Sheriff's Office · Los Angeles County, CA

    Armed private security guards at Northrop Grumman Plant 42 approached a person filming from outside the facility. In the transcript, a guard says taking pictures is suspicious, that guards must investigate, and that they have to assume possible malicious intent. The photographer repeatedly says he does not have to state his purpose or identify himself and that he is on a public right of way. A guard cites the authority that comes with being uniformed and armed. The narrator states that a Los Angeles County Sheriff deputy later arrived and declined to make an arrest, but that part is not in the transcript provided.

  • Orlando post office auditor told he is not detained after employee calls police

    Orlando Police Department · Orlando, FL

    Officers respond to a U.S. Post Office in Orlando after an employee called police about a man filming inside. The man says he is conducting a First Amendment audit and asks for officers' names and badge numbers. An officer gives a name, and one officer is heard giving a badge number. A bystander says the caller falsely claimed the man made threats. When the man asks whether he is detained, an officer says no and that he is free to leave and is choosing to stay. An officer says employees notify a supervisor whenever there is an auditor. The narrator says the encounter ended without detention or arrest.

  • Mooresville officer asks recording citizen for name and mentions phone search warrant at crash scene

    Mooresville Police Department · Mooresville, NC

    A citizen recorded a traffic accident scene on Route 150 near a Wendy's in Mooresville, North Carolina (per the description). The officer told her the footage could be evidence and that he could petition for a search warrant for her phone. He asked repeatedly for her name and date of birth, and said she could be placed under arrest if she did not give them. She refused, saying she had not committed a crime and was recording in public. The officer later said he might contact her for the video if needed. Afterward the citizen said he had mentioned arrest for obstruction and that his supervisor appeared to tell him something. The transcript does not show an arrest.

  • Yazoo City officers tell man filming banks from sidewalk to leave and ask for ID

    Yazoo City Police Department · Yazoo City, MS

    The narrator states a man was recording several banks from what he identified as a public sidewalk in downtown Yazoo City, Mississippi, after employees reported feeling uncomfortable. Officers told him to leave the area or go to jail and asked for identification, which he declined to give, saying he had not committed a crime. An officer acknowledged that filming is not against the law and that he did not have to give ID, and a sergeant became involved in a heated exchange with the man. A detective also arrived and the man again refused to give his name. The narrator frames the legal questions around Turner v. Driver and Brown v. Texas; no arrest is shown in the transcript.

  • West Chicago officer orders protesters off disputed church frontage under threat of arrest

    West Chicago Police Department · West Chicago, IL

    Protesters were outside St. Andrew Lutheran Church. An officer told them to move across the street, saying the spot was church property and that they could not impede traffic or block access to the church. The protesters said the area was a public easement and asked whether the officer would arrest them. The officer said yes, that they would be arrested if they stayed. He also said he had been an officer for over 25 years and was in charge. The exchange grew heated on both sides, with the officer repeating his order and the protesters calling him names.

  • Auditor filming outside Fort Smith coffee shop questioned about recording customers

    Fort Smith Police Department · Fort Smith, AR

    The description says employees called police about auditors recording customers and license plates from a public sidewalk outside a coffee shop in Fort Smith. In the transcript, a woman repeatedly asks the auditor why he is recording, and he says it is for his boss. She says she may talk to people inside and call the non-emergency line. She also objects to being filmed and says she will get his license plate. The responding officer's statements, including the description's claim that he said he could not force the auditors to identify themselves, are not clearly captured in the transcript. The narrator says the filming from a public sidewalk generally presents a stronger position for the auditors.

  • Santa Ana officers order auditor to back up; cameraman alleges use of force

    Santa Ana Police Department · Santa Ana, CA

    The narrator states this occurred in Santa Ana, California in July 2023, when a First Amendment auditor filmed officers at an active scene. An officer repeatedly told the cameraman to back up and said he was impeding an investigation. The cameraman asked for a name and badge number, and an officer gave what is heard as "Kim 3198". The cameraman said "use of force" and demanded a sergeant so he could file a complaint. An officer is heard saying "I'm pushing you back", and the cameraman repeatedly called this use of force. Other officers later set up tape and told the cameraman where to stand.

  • Galveston officers respond to neighbor noise dispute and discuss speech and disorderly conduct

    Galveston Police Department · Galveston, TX

    Officers respond to a neighbor dispute over loud music at an address given by the narrator as 3419 Sealy Ave. Residents say they asked the neighbor by text to lower the music, and say she used racial slurs toward them and swung at one of them. The officer says that calling people slurs is against the law, and the recording citizen disagrees and says it is protected speech. The officer tells the residents and the neighbor to keep the music at a low level until the residents move out Thursday, and advises them to call police rather than confront her. The narrator states the officer misstated speech law and cites Texas Penal Code 42.01.

  • Dayton, Tennessee officers check on cleaner inside closed doctor's office at night

    Dayton Police Department · Dayton, TN

    Officers found an unfamiliar car and a man inside a closed doctor's office after hours. They wanted to identify him and confirm he belonged there. The man, who said he was a cleaner, would not come out or identify himself. Officers said they saw a cleaning cart and that he had been cleaning, and they said they could not force him out because the door was unlocked. The cleaner's mother-in-law and an office assistant said he cleans the building every night, and the mother-in-law alleged he was targeted because he is Black. The officers denied this and said they were checking the building. The narrator criticizes the officers for continuing the encounter.

  • Indiana state trooper confronted over identification during 2020 protest

    Indiana State Police · Indiana State, IN

    The narrator states that in Indiana in the summer of 2020, a trooper refused to identify himself and then alleged an assault had occurred. In the audio, people repeatedly asked an officer for his name and badge number, and he asked whether they were refusing to identify and said he saw someone pushing and that they were in an unauthorized area. People in the crowd made profane statements and a confrontation over distancing and masks is audible. The narrator gave the citizen a B+ and the trooper a C, citing limited explanation during the encounter.

  • Sutton police officer speaks with auditor filming outside church

    Sutton Police Department · Sutton, MA

    The narrator states that in December 2024 an auditor was filming outside a church in Sutton, Massachusetts, and a church member who claimed law enforcement experience confronted him about it. Police were then called, and an officer asked what the auditor was doing and said the church members were concerned. The officer acknowledged the right to record but described public access to private property in a way the narrator's commentary calls imprecise, including saying a person could not be trespassed from a Walmart unless causing a disturbance. The encounter ended cordially, and the narrator graded the officer C+ and the auditor A minus.

  • Boston City Hall employees question auditor's recording; officer speaks with him

    Boston Police Department · Boston, MA

    An auditor recorded inside publicly accessible areas of Boston City Hall and was questioned by several employees. Some employees told him he needed permission or that people were uncomfortable being filmed, and a labor relations director said her office was not public facing and held confidential information. The auditor said he had a First Amendment right to record and stayed in publicly accessible areas. A uniformed officer, heard as 'Cody or Kobe', spoke with him cordially and asked him not to aggravate anyone. The narrator's commentary cites Glik v. Cunniffe and says discomfort with a camera does not settle the constitutional question.

  • Cook County deputies respond to filming dispute at courthouse lobby

    Cook County Sheriff's Office · Cook County, IL

    At the Cook County courthouse complex in Markham, an auditor submitted FOIA requests at several departments. A Social Services supervisor and a Public Defender's Office employee objected to being filmed, and someone called for the sheriff. Deputies arrived, spoke with the auditor about his FOIA request, and told him filming in the public lobby is within his rights, excluding courtrooms and private attorney-client conversations. Deputies helped locate a FOIA form, and the exchange ended cordially. The narrator gave the deputies an A minus.

  • Louisville Metro officer takes man to ground during arrest after roadside test dispute

    Louisville Metro Police Department · Louisville Metro, KY

    During a traffic stop, a Louisville Metro Police officer told the driver he had seen an item under the seat that he said the driver had hidden and called it tampering with evidence. The driver agreed to take a roadside test, but the officer ordered him to turn around and then to the ground, radioed that the man was fighting, and arrested him for resisting. On bodycam audio the man says he is not resisting, that he is being hurt and that his nose is bleeding, while officers kneel on him after he is handcuffed; another officer says he is already cuffed and should be put in a car.

  • Irvine officers repeatedly question filming auditor outside police station; complaint forms requested

    Irvine Police Department · Irvine, CA

    A man filming outside the Irvine police station was approached by officers who asked why he was there and whether he was on probation or parole. They also asked his name. He said he was not breaking the law, declined to answer questions, and said he would film every car and person. Officers said they were free to ask questions and that the man did not have to answer. They said they approached because video showed unusual activity at a gate, which the man disputed. The officers gave names and badge numbers when asked, and the man asked for two complaint forms to report harassment. An officer said the city, not he, holds the forms and that a supervisor would handle it.

  • Independent journalist physically restrained at Leon Valley Police Department media event

    Leon Valley Police Department · Leon Valley, TX

    At the Leon Valley Police Department in Texas, an independent journalist tried to follow another media crew into a meeting. He was told the other crew had an interview on the other side of the building. He was also told he could bring a camera to the meeting but could not set up beforehand. He repeatedly asked whether all media were being allowed in and why that media was let in but not him. An officer said they were not open, and physical contact followed. He said he was not resisting and was told he was under arrest for obstruction.

  • Valparaiso officer ends ID demand during call about filming at COVID-19 testing site

    Valparaiso Police Department · Valparaiso, IN

    Staff at a COVID-19 testing site tell an auditor that filming patients from the sidewalk is a HIPAA violation and on private property, and say they will call police. The officer says the auditor is allowed to film from public property and should stay off the property. He asks for ID and says people involved in a police call are compelled to ID. The auditor refuses and says reasonable articulable suspicion of a crime is required. The officer says he would identify the auditor if staff said he was on their property. After the auditor says he stayed on the sidewalk and offers video proof, the officer says he is fine and leaves.

  • North Andover officers respond to photography call; dispute over officer name request

    North Andover Police Department · North Andover, MA

    Police were dispatched after a report of a person photographing the property of the Greater Lawrence Sanitary District, according to dispatch audio and the description. The man filming asked a detective for his name and badge number, and the detective (heard as Gilligan) told him to step back from a cruiser. The exchange became heated, with the man citing Massachusetts General Laws Chapter 41 Section 98D and the detective saying the man had approached him. Two other officers later gave a name and badge number when asked. A patrol sergeant then spoke with the man, said he had the right to take pictures, asked about the restricted road toward a National Grid area, and confirmed the man could remain in the publicly accessible area as long as he did not pass the posted gate.

  • Winder officer accepts ID refusal during possible panhandling check

    Winder Police Department · Winder, GA

    An officer approaches a man outside Winder City Hall and the police department, where a call had come in as possible panhandling. The officer asks whether the man is asking for money, and the man says he is only saying 'God bless the homeless veterans'. The officer asks for ID, and the man declines but gives his first name. After confirming the man is not panhandling, the officer tells him he is good and ends the contact. The narrator describes the officer as accepting the refusal and de-escalating.

  • El Segundo officers respond to dispute over filming near Air Force base

    El Segundo Police Department · El Segundo, CA

    A man filming from a public sidewalk near the Los Angeles Air Force Base and another man exchange insults, and one of them repeatedly asks for federal security forces to be contacted. When El Segundo officers arrive, one man tells them the other grabbed his camera and pulled it down, and that he pushed or kicked the man off in response. The other man states he is a federal employee with identification and describes being approached with a camera. The transcript does not show how the officers resolved the call. The narrator adds commentary on the Ninth Circuit's recognition of a right to record and on police needing to work out who started the confrontation.

  • Skokie police respond to security complaint about recording at state human services office

    Skokie Police Department · Skokie, IL

    Security staff at the Illinois Department of Human Services office in Skokie call police about an auditor recording in the lobby. Officer Hernandez is described as initially raising the possibility of removal and as not giving his name at first. A second Skokie officer says the auditor may record in publicly accessible areas if he does not enter restricted areas, interfere with employees, or break the law. He says a commander had told officers at roll call that this activity is acceptable. The officers leave. The auditor then files a FOIA request, and a verbal confrontation with a security employee follows.

  • Spokane deputies respond to records request dispute at SCOPE North

    Spokane County Sheriff's Office · Spokane County, WA

    According to the description, an auditor went to SCOPE North in Spokane, Washington to submit a public records request. Staff said they could not help, and the auditor declined to give his name and asked whether he was free to be in a public lobby. A deputy, heard as "Pendel," and others asked him to leave, and at one point a voice says he would be arrested if he did not. The deputies suggested he write the request on paper and submit it to the records officer. The auditor says a sheriff's deputy called city police, and he continued dictating records requests to the deputy and to volunteers present.

  • White County deputy disarms driver during brake light stop

    White County Sheriff's Office · White County, TN

    A White County deputy stops a driver over a brake light and orders him out of the vehicle. The driver questions this, and the deputy cites Pennsylvania v. Mimms. The driver says he has a firearm on his hip and another on his ankle. The deputy disarms him for the remainder of the stop. The driver objects, says it violates his Second Amendment rights, and asks for a supervisor. The deputy says the driver having guns is the reason. The two argue about fear and officer safety, and the driver accuses the deputy of pointing a gun at him. The deputy returns the firearms and issues a verbal warning, and the driver is told he is free to leave.

  • Pawtucket captain and officers confront citizens filming inside City Hall

    Pawtucket Police Department · Pawtucket, RI

    Citizens recording in a publicly accessible lobby of a city building that includes the tax collector's office are told by a captain that a sign prohibits phones or photos. The citizens state that policy is not law and ask whether they are detained or being given lawful orders. The captain says the city can set policy for the building and that staff reported a camera was put through a window. The citizens deny this. They ask for his reasonable articulable suspicion and cite 12-7-1 regarding identification. The captain tells them he will ask them to leave if they have no official business.

  • Scottsdale officers discuss filming and jurisdiction with auditors at post office

    Scottsdale Police Department · Scottsdale, AZ

    Officers responded to a Scottsdale post office after a dispute between people filming and a member of the public. The auditors said they had written authorization from the postmaster and argued that only the postal inspector could enforce laws on the property. A sergeant said Arizona law applies and that the officers do have jurisdiction. He also said the manager reported the auditor kept recording a woman after she asked not to be filmed, which the sergeant said made her agitated. The auditor disagreed, said he could not be told what to do unless he broke the law, and the conversation ended with no arrest or citation heard.

  • Providence police officers discuss filming a post office clerk in public lobby

    Providence Police Department · Providence, RI

    The narrator states this occurred in November 2018 at a United States Post Office in Providence, Rhode Island, after police had been called twice. A sergeant or officer asked the auditor not to film the clerk's face, saying she did not want to be on video. The auditor said he had a right to film government employees in public areas. The officer said he would not let the auditor in with the filming of her face unless a judge ruled otherwise and said it was a judgment call. The auditor ultimately agreed not to record her face, and they went inside together.

  • Summit police respond to post office call over recording and ask auditor for ID

    Summit Police Department · Summit, IL

    At the Summit post office, a postal employee told an auditor it is illegal to videotape federal buildings and said he would call police. Officers arrived and asked the auditor for ID to run. The auditor declined and gave only a first name, and the officers did not press the matter. The auditor said he was filing a records request for the employee's phone video. During the discussion an officer told the supervising clerk that if the post office wanted to, they could trespass the auditor. The auditor asked for what crime, and an officer said it could be because of a claim that he was disrupting customers. The narrator cites 39 CFR 232.1 and Illinois law on identification.

  • Santa Ana deputies and sergeant order recording citizen away from traffic collision scene

    Orange County Sheriff's Office · Orange County, CA

    A citizen journalist recorded an active traffic collision investigation in Santa Ana, California. A deputy told him to move about 10 feet away and said he would be handcuffed and taken to Orange County Jail for obstructing the investigation if he did not. The deputy said he could record all he wanted if he stayed out of the scene. The cameraman repeatedly asked for names and badge numbers, and the transcript gives several. After the involved vehicle was cleared, the deputy said everyone was free to go. The cameraman asked a sergeant for a complaint against the deputy, and the transcript does not show the outcome.

  • Fort Walton Beach officers respond to bank call about auditor on public sidewalk

    Fort Walton Beach Police Department · Fort Walton Beach, FL

    Police were called by bank staff about a First Amendment auditor photographing the bank and its drive-through customers from a public sidewalk. Officer Jeffrey told the auditor he was within his rights to film on public property but that the bank did not want him on its property. The officer said he could not force the auditor to identify himself since no crime had been committed, and he gave his name and badge number. A bank manager objected to the filming. A second officer reminded the auditor not to block the sidewalk. A lieutenant later said they would leave and that nothing illegal was happening. The auditor said he had not yet reviewed the bodycam and gave the officers a favorable assessment so far, and the narrator grades the officers B+ to A minus.

  • Pasco officer declines business card request and discusses traffic stops

    Pasco Police Department · Pasco, WA

    An auditor approached Pasco Police officers and repeatedly asked for a business card. Officer Hill said he had cards but would give one only if assisting with a case. He told the auditor to call non-emergency or 911 so whoever was working could help. The auditor then raised license plates on Teslas, asked about ID requests during traffic stops, and raised 'right to travel' arguments. The officer said he pulls over vehicles without plates and that officers follow Washington law. The exchange stayed calm, with no detention shown. The narrator says Officer Hill showed patience.

  • Rockwall courthouse deputy asks photographer for search consent and ID

    Rockwall County Sheriff's Office · Rockwall County, TX

    A man photographing a courthouse building and employee vehicle license plates was approached by a uniformed deputy who said people had been concerned about the photos. The man said he was photographing what he could see from public and doing journalist work. The deputy asked where he was coming from, whether he had anything illegal, and whether he could check him, and the man declined the search. The deputy also asked for ID, which the man said he did not have, and the deputy said he was only asking and the man did not have to give up his rights. The narrator characterizes the questioning as a fishing expedition.

  • Panama City officer questions man holding sign for homeless veterans and warns of 'consequences'

    Panama City Police Department · Panama City, FL

    At the Downtown Farmers Market, a man was holding a sign reading 'God bless the homeless' and asking for prayers for homeless veterans. An officer who introduced himself as Jeff approached and engaged him in conversation. The man said he did not want to answer personal questions. The officer said no one had called about him. He then told the man to look up Panama City codes and Florida statutes because a sign might violate them depending on what it says. When the man declined to look them up, the officer asked whether he would rather deal with the consequences. The officer then left, and the man stayed at the location.

  • Officer questions Canadian tourist's license and insurance during traffic contact

    Costa Mesa Police Department · Costa Mesa, CA

    A driver who says he is a Canadian tourist is told by an officer that a records check shows no California license was ever issued to him. The driver says he holds a Canadian license and had given the officer his insurance, and the two disagree about what paperwork was provided. The officer asks for physical descriptors and vehicle registration details, and at one point tells the driver he will receive a citation for impeding traffic. The driver apologizes and the officer ends the contact with 'no worries,' so the transcript does not clearly show whether a citation was issued. The narrator says California Vehicle Code 12502 generally allows a nonresident to drive on a valid license from their home jurisdiction, and grades the officer a C.

  • Yelm officer speaks with journalist at school district office during records dispute

    Yelm Police Department · Yelm, WA

    An independent journalist asked staff at the Yelm Community Schools District Office for a records index and published procedures manual under Washington public records law. Staff asked him for his information on a records request, and he disputed that he needed to make a request for materials he said must be prominently displayed. An officer arrived and spoke with him. The officer said he is not a school resource officer, that the dispute appeared to be a civil issue, and that he would relay the journalist's request to the superintendent. The journalist said he was not asked to leave.

  • LAPD officers and man in parked car dispute gang assumptions and badge number request

    Los Angeles Police Department · Los Angeles, CA

    The narrator states that in December 2022 a Los Angeles police encounter became a heated debate over racial profiling and gang assumptions. A man sitting in a parked car says officers linked his blue clothing to a gang, and an officer is heard saying he is not citing him for wearing blue. The man asks for officers' names and badge numbers, and says he was cited for parking or an alcohol violation only after asking. An officer is heard asking whether the man had ever had someone in a car shoot at him, explaining the officers' safety concerns. The man says he keeps a record of officers who come to his driveway and says officers visit repeatedly. The narrator says suspicion must rest on specific facts, not race or clothing color, and grades the police C minus and the citizen B minus.

  • Greer police respond to man filming in state human services lobby

    Greer Police Department · Greer, SC

    The narrator states that in June 2016 in Greer, South Carolina, a citizen filming in a Department of Human Services lobby became the center of a confrontation over identification and recording. Staff said recording was not allowed because people were giving confidential information, and the filmer said privacy protection was the building's responsibility. Staff called police. The responding officer asked for ID and the filmer declined, and officers and a supervisor then told the filmer to leave, citing criminal trespass and disorderly conduct. The filmer said he would accept arrest rather than leave and that he had made an appointment. The narrator says Terry v. Ohio was referenced and that the encounter escalated to an arrest and jail booking, though the arrest is not shown in the portion of the transcript provided.

  • Chicago detail officer parked on sidewalk with emergency lights disputes with auditor

    Chicago Police Department · Chicago, IL

    An auditor tells an officer parked on a sidewalk that he is blocking the walkway and running emergency lights without an emergency. The officer says he is on a special detail, keeping watch on a fixed post, and offers to back up so the auditor can pass. The auditor says people have to walk around the vehicle and asks for a supervisor. The officer says a supervisor is on the way. The narrator says the transcript never provides a clear legal explanation for the sidewalk blocking.

  • Pasco traffic stop: officers tell recording man to keep distance after his father is placed in a patrol car

    Pasco Police Department · Pasco, WA

    At a police traffic stop in Pasco, Washington, a man arrived and said his father, who regularly records police, had been put in a patrol car. He said his father's camera was on the floor. Officers told him he could record from farther away, at the stop sign, but not near their investigation. The man said he was on public property, asked for badge numbers and a sergeant, and said he would sue if touched. Officers said they did not know who his father was or where he was. The narrator says it is unclear what happened before filming started.

  • Selma officer and auditor have friendly conversation about filming police

    Selma Police Department · Selma, TX

    The narrator states that in October 2022 in Selma, Texas, an officer approached a First Amendment auditor and the two talked. The officer said he recognized the auditor from his videos and that he had been on the job about six and a half years. The auditor explained he began filming Border Patrol checkpoints and later moved to filming police generally, saying he highlights good officers and exposes bad ones. The officer said the department has nothing to hide, and the two parted on friendly terms. The narrator describes this as an example of professional interaction.

  • NYPD officers question photographer outside facility and say he is not free to go

    New York City Police Department · New York City, NY

    A man photographing police vehicles near an NYPD facility in New York City is stopped by officers who say he is acting suspiciously. He repeatedly asks whether he is detained or free to go, what crime is being investigated, and whether he must answer questions. Officers say they are investigating and asking questions, and one says that looking inside police vehicles could be criminal mischief. The man says he is recording police activity in public, asks for a business card and a CCRB complaint form, and says he will not answer questions. The narrator then discusses Terry v. Ohio and says the key issue is what specific facts justified restricting his freedom.

  • NYPD officer and auditor dispute recording and ID request outside precinct

    New York City Police Department · New York City, NY

    An auditor recording outside an NYPD precinct is approached by an officer who asks for ID, citing an apparent open container. The auditor says the container is a 0% alcohol beverage and asks what crime is suspected. The officer says the auditor is too close to the precinct and cannot film inside police cars, and the auditor says he is on a public sidewalk. The two exchange insults and repeated accusations of touching and crowding, and the auditor repeatedly asks for the officer's card and a sergeant. The officer tells the auditor to see his shield number and says he will stay at the scene.

  • Dickinson officer responds to HHS office call about auditors recording

    Dickinson Police Department · Dickinson, TX

    Two auditors recorded inside a Texas Health and Human Services office while asking staff for names and a list of employees, which they described as a public records request. An employee said she felt harassed and intimidated and told the auditors she had called the police. The auditors stayed in the lobby to wait for officers, and one relayed that he was told they were not supposed to be loitering in the lobby. When an auditor asked whether they would be arrested for loitering if they did not leave, the response in the transcript is "no," and the auditor said "awesome." The narrator then says the restriction on filming depends on whether it was reasonable, neutral and consistently enforced, and notes no clear physical obstruction in the transcript.

  • Oklahoma City officer tells dispensary staff sidewalk filming is lawful

    Oklahoma City Police Department · Oklahoma City, OK

    Auditors filmed from a public sidewalk outside a cannabis dispensary in Oklahoma City. A customer and staff objected to being filmed and asked about privacy. The auditors asked a staff member for the Wi-Fi password. A dispensary employee called the police. An Oklahoma City police officer arrived, and an auditor says the officer told the employee the auditors were on a public sidewalk and protected. The officer is also said to have advised them not to go onto the property. The auditors asked for a call-for-service number.

  • Boca Raton officers respond to call about sign holder soliciting in park

    Boca Raton Police Department · Boca Raton, FL

    Park staff told a citizen holding a sign at a park that asking for money was not allowed and said they would call police. Officers arrived, said they had received a call about solicitation, and told the citizen that asking for money was not allowed in the city. The citizen said asking for money is protected speech and declined to answer some questions. An officer later said they had no city ordinance about soliciting in the park, though that could change, and said that if people call in, officers would return. The citizen was told early on that he could not leave but was not being detained, and the encounter ended cordially.

  • Pasco officers direct recording citizens to stay back from active police scene

    Pasco Police Department · Pasco, WA

    Citizens recording an active police scene in Pasco, Washington, say they are on public property at a safe distance and have a right to record. Officers set a boundary, and one citizen says he will stay about 10 feet away. A woman tells an officer or supervisor that her husband was earlier handcuffed for walking on the sidewalk, and says she plans to file a complaint. The narrator says the right to record is protected but not unlimited, and that police may enforce lawful safety and traffic restrictions. The narrator cites Ninth Circuit precedent and RCW 46.61.021 on traffic-stop detention and identification.

  • Hickman police detain and pat down man filming City Hall after ID dispute

    Hickman Police Department · Hickman, KY

    The narrator states that a citizen filming a public government building in Hickman, Kentucky, declined to hand over ID. An officer repeatedly asked for identification, saying the person had to provide it and that he would otherwise be placed in the patrol car and detained. The man asked whether he was being detained and asked what suspicion the officer had. The officer later did a pat down, citing his own protection, and the man's camera was taken. The narrator says the detention lasted about 10 minutes. The chief of police later said 12 to 15 minutes was reasonable to learn why someone was filming a government building, told the man he was free to go, and gave his name and badge number.

  • Lewis County corrections sergeant questions man filming near Sally port

    Lewis County Sheriff's Office · Lewis County, NY

    A man filming outside the Lewis County Correctional Facility is approached by a person identified in the transcript as a corrections sergeant, who asks who he is and why he is filming the Sally port. The filmer says he is looking at construction. The sergeant calls for a patrol unit and says he is a peace officer for the County of Lewis. When a deputy sheriff sergeant arrives, he asks for the filmer's name and badge number. The sergeant says he will explain only if the filmer identifies himself, and the filmer declines. The filmer asks whether it is department policy to identify to the public, and the sergeant says it is not, but should be a matter of professionalism.

  • Jeffersonville police tell auditor areas near station are restricted and issue trespass warning

    Jeffersonville Police Department · Jeffersonville, IN

    The narrator states that in Jeffersonville, Indiana, a First Amendment auditor was recording outside a police department building. Officers told the auditor he could not go further because it was police department property and a restricted area, and said he would be arrested for trespassing if he went past a certain point. The auditor asked whether he was being detained, asked for names and badge numbers, and asked where signs were posted; officers said no signs were needed, and at one point the auditor said officers did not seem to know where the boundary was. Officers gave a trespass warning and one said to make sure the auditor was trespassed from the property. The narrator gave the officers a C and the auditor a B+.

  • Varnville officer orders auditor to stop filming in health facility and demands ID

    Varnville Police Department · Varnville, SC

    An auditor recorded inside a government health facility, where employees said he had been asked to leave and was filming after being asked not to. An officer told him to leave or face arrest, ordered the camera turned off, and took him to a vehicle to get information. The officer demanded physical ID, said South Carolina law requires carrying it, and threatened arrest and a driving-without-a-license charge when the auditor said he had none with him. The auditor asked repeatedly for the statute and the officer did not cite one in the transcript. After the auditor invoked silence, the officer said he would arrest him and warned of a trespass charge if he returned without an escort.

  • NYPD officers respond to cameraman's complaint about intoxicated man on Brooklyn sidewalk

    New York City Police Department · New York City, NY

    A cameraman recording from a public sidewalk in Bensonhurst, Brooklyn, says an intoxicated man approached him and grabbed his arm twice. He demands that the man be arrested and asks for a sergeant and for body cameras to be on. Officers say they did not witness harassment, that a summons requires an officer to observe the violation, and that officers have discretion. One officer says grabbing is not assault unless there is injury and calls it harassment, which is a violation. Officers say the cameraman may keep recording and that nobody told him he could not record. They say they called an ambulance for the intoxicated man.

  • Ada police detain armed citizen at skate park after report of firearm

    Ada Police Department · Ada, OK

    In Ada, Oklahoma, a female officer approached an armed citizen at a skate park after a call that someone had a gun. She said he was fine under constitutional carry, then asked for his ID. He declined, saying he had not committed a crime. A second officer said an off-duty officer had seen him brandishing the weapon; the citizen denied it. When he asked if he was free to go, an officer said he was not, and cited brandishing as the suspected crime. A supervisor later said the call reported the firearm showing under his shirt, told him he could carry, and the encounter ended with no arrest.

  • San Angelo officers arrest father at Walmart after ID refusal, sergeant orders release

    San Angelo Police Department · San Angelo, TX

    Officers responded to a Walmart for a report of an intoxicated driver with a young child. A man identified as Jack refused to give identification. Officers told him he would be arrested for failure to ID and that CPS would be called. The narrator states they pinned him against a refrigerator and used pain compliance techniques, and took him to a cruiser while a Walmart employee took his son. Sergeant Holt arrived, concluded the failure to identify charge did not fit, and ordered his release. In a later recorded interview an officer said he misunderstood the law, saying 'I screwed up'.

  • Deputy and auditor dispute identification outside Gregg County Jail in Longview

    Gregg County Sheriff's Office · Gregg County, TX

    The narrator states a First Amendment auditor was recording from a public area outside the Gregg County Jail in Longview, Texas when a deputy approached. The deputy asked what he was doing and told him to leave the property or risk criminal trespass. The auditor asked what crime he had committed, cited Texas Penal Code 38.02, and repeatedly demanded the deputy's name and badge number, citing sheriff's office policy. The deputy declined to give his name at first. The auditor used insulting language and the deputy gave little response. The auditor read a name tag as 'Mitchell' and the deputy left.

  • Riverside officers check on masked man recording outside bank

    Riverside Police Department · Riverside, MO

    Officers responded to a call from a bank whose employees were worried about a masked man recording people coming and going. The officer said he was not accusing the man of doing anything wrong and wanted to be able to tell the bank it was okay. The man said he was making a positive video and that the mask was for Covid. The officer told him recording was legal, and the encounter stayed conversational, including a short quiz on the Constitution. The officer's remarks as heard, and the narrator's later summary, say no ID was requested and no detention or crime was found. A corporal also took part, and the man gave a first name only when asked for it for a call number.

  • Omaha officers question independent journalist filming inside Douglas County government building

    Omaha Police Department · Omaha, NE

    Two Omaha police officers respond to a call about a man recording inside the Douglas County Government Center, near the Treasurer's Office. The journalist says he is taking pictures and video for a story. One officer says staff found the recording suspicious, suggests the man could be scoping the place out to rob it, and asks him to leave. The journalist declines to give his last name or ID, asks whether the officer has reasonable articulable suspicion of a crime, and asks for a supervisor. A Douglas County deputy later arrives and agrees there is no issue with taking pictures and video in publicly accessible areas.

  • Bernalillo County deputies respond to noise complaint and dispute over entry through closed gate

    Bernalillo County Sheriff's Office · Bernalillo County, NM

    The narrator states deputies in Bernalillo County, New Mexico responded to a noise complaint about loud music. The homeowner repeatedly told them to leave his property and said his gate was closed. The deputies said they had a lawful reason to be there and mentioned a noise ordinance. When asked, the homeowner declined to provide ID, and the deputies provided badge numbers when asked. The narrator discusses the implied license doctrine and curtilage, and the encounter ended with the deputies leaving.

  • NYPD officers tell person to stop recording inside parked patrol car

    New York City Police Department · New York City, NY

    A person filming a parked NYPD vehicle is approached by officers who ask if he needs help. A female officer tells him to stop recording the vehicle's interior. The filmer asks if he is detained and says he can record anything visible from a public place. The officers say he is not detained, that they were checking on him, and that no one told him to stop recording in general. A male officer gives his name and badge number and the female officer later gives the filmer a card. The male officer says the filmer is free to exercise his rights but should not damage the vehicle, or he would be arrested.

  • Lynnwood officers question man filming at Fire Station 15 and discuss trespass

    Lynnwood Police Department · Lynnwood, WA

    Officers responded to Fire Department Station 15 after staff reportedly were uncomfortable with a man photographing and filming, including through windows. An officer said he had seen the man looking into windows and taking photos inside offices, and the man said he was filming from public space and declined to explain his purpose. The officer repeatedly warned about possible removal or trespass, and the man asked if he was being detained, to which the officer said no. A supervisor was requested at the man's request, and the supervisor raised the idea of 'operational obstruction' and said a battalion chief was concerned for the safety of occupants. No arrest or trespass is shown in the transcript.

  • Danbury library officers demand ID from man filming, cite policy and threaten arrest

    Danbury Police Department · Danbury, CT

    Officers responded to a public library after a library representative asked a man filming to leave. The man said he was exercising First Amendment rights. Officers told him he was being detained, that the library's policy required identifying him so he could be given a trespass notice, and that refusing ID could lead to arrest and custody. A supervisor was called at the man's request. The man said he would comply with lawful orders, warned of possible lawsuit, and said that under threat of arrest he would provide his ID. The narrator rates the police performance poorly for coercive ID demands.

  • NYC officers arrest man over alleged open container and ID dispute

    New York City Police Department · New York City, NY

    A man standing near a vehicle is approached by officers who ask why he was looking inside it and tell him he has an open container. The man repeatedly says he does not drink alcohol, asks what crime or violation is alleged, and demands a body camera and a sergeant. An officer says he was lawfully stopped for an open container of alcohol and asks for ID, and the man refuses and asks for probable cause. Officers say "you're under arrest" and attempt to take him inside, while the man tells them not to touch him. The narrator says the officers appear to rely on an alleged open container violation and that whether legal standards were met is a central question.

  • Harrison NY officers ask photographer for ID outside post office

    Harrison Town Police Department · Harrison Town, NY

    The narrator states that outside a USPS facility in Harrison, New York, two officers responded to calls from postal employees or residents about a person photographing the building. The officers asked why he was taking pictures and then asked for his ID. The citizen repeatedly asked what crime he was suspected of. The officers cited calls and a number of mailbox thefts in the area. They said they did not say he had committed a crime. The citizen asked if he was detained, and an officer said no. He was told he was free to go and the encounter ended.

  • Surprise police officers respond to photographer after he is asked to leave civic center building

    Surprise Police Department · Surprise, AZ

    In Arizona, a photographer filming at the Surprise Police Department and Civic Center area says a security guard asked him to leave a building after he went in, and that three officers then surrounded him. An officer who identifies himself as Fernando Lamas explains that city municipal code allows recording outside but not inside the courts or City Hall. The photographer says the posted sign mentions only weapons and suggests adding a sign about cameras. The officer says he does not control signage and that police often receive calls about this issue. The conversation ends cordially, and the photographer thanks the officers for their help.

  • Warren officers detain photographer outside federal facility after caller complaint

    Warren Police Department · Warren, MI

    The narrator states that in May 2017, outside a federal facility in Warren, Michigan, a First Amendment auditor filming in public was surrounded, detained and ordered to identify himself. An officer said they were investigating a crime because someone called, and also said he did not suspect the auditor of committing anything right now, while maintaining the auditor was detained and had to identify himself. Officers cited a Warren ordinance requiring identification when someone calls about a possible crime. The auditor repeatedly asked what crime was suspected, and later asked for a department card, a chief's name and a supervisor. The auditor also demanded an officer be charged with disorderly conduct for swearing, and an officer said that was not against the law.

  • Greene County sergeant confronts auditor at government building over filming and harassment claim

    Greene County Sheriff's Office · Greene County, MO

    A Greene County sheriff's sergeant, who gave his number as 2804, approached an auditor filming inside a public benefits office. The sergeant said staff had called about harassment and that a door sign said recording was prohibited under state policy. The auditor asked about the difference between policy and law and asked what crime was alleged. The auditor also remarked on the sergeant's hand on his gun, and the sergeant said that was how he normally stood. The sergeant said he would not take the auditor and put him in a cage. He later told the auditor he was free to leave, and the auditor stayed. The narrator says staff were no longer present by the end.

  • Security and state police at New York State Capitol confront auditors filming

    New York State Police · New York State, NY

    The narrator states that in Albany, New York, two auditors filmed public areas inside the New York State Capitol. A security officer told them to leave, and the auditors said he had no authority over them. A badge number was given as 519. Several armed officers gathered, and the auditors asked repeatedly whether they were detained or free to go. An officer was heard warning them to keep their voices down to avoid a disorderly conduct allegation. The auditors left or were dismissed without any arrest stated.

  • Lee County captain demands ID from auditor over alleged school property trespass

    Lee County Sheriff's Office · Lee County, FL

    An auditor filming at a training facility, described in the video as a school-district-owned site where officers train, was confronted by a Lee County Sheriff's Office captain and other personnel. The auditor said he left the property when told to and was on the sidewalk. The captain said the auditor was detained pending investigation of trespassing on school grounds and cited Florida Statute 810.097. The captain said he would take the auditor to jail for trespassing if he did not provide ID. The auditor said he had open cases and gave his ID to avoid arrest, while stating he was recording the threat of arrest for a later complaint.

  • Sebring officers detain armed fisherman near city pier after 911 calls

    Sebring Police Department · Sebring, FL

    Officers responded to calls about a person in body armor with a rifle walking toward a city fishing pier. A fisherman who was openly carrying a firearm says an officer pointed a gun at him with a finger on the trigger, and the fisherman says his hands were up and demanded the officer stand down. Another officer or supervisor also told the officer to stand down. The fisherman demanded names and badge numbers, and several officers gave them. Officers explained the call and referred to a recent incident in Texas as context; the fisherman said he was not breaking the law and asked for the call number.

  • Peoria officers and sergeants answer auditor's questions at police facility

    Peoria Police Department · Peoria, AZ

    An auditor questions officers at a police facility about staffing, equipment programs and department operations. An officer says he is waiting for his supervisor to arrive and give him a handoff, and the auditor accuses him of lying about the sergeant's availability. The auditor then speaks with a field training sergeant and a second sergeant, who answers questions about department size (about 200 sworn), the population of Peoria (about 175,000), and past participation in the DOD 1033 program. The auditor also makes remarks about a flag and asks about police versus peace officer duties. Officers answer the questions and the exchange ends without any stated arrest or citation.

  • Pasco officers speak with citizen about park ranger complaints

    Pasco Police Department · Pasco, WA

    In Pasco, Washington, a citizen recorder spoke with patrol officers, including a sergeant, about a park ranger. The citizen alleged that the ranger took people's belongings from near a mission and that the ranger ran over people with a vehicle in a park. An officer said people could file complaints or call, and said he would reach out to the city. The officers were largely conversational and did not detain anyone in the footage. The narrator frames this as protected inquiry and observation.

  • Mesa officer with rifle stands near auditors filming outside police scene

    Mesa Police Department · Mesa, AZ

    The narrator states that in October 2019 First Amendment auditors recorded officers from a public sidewalk outside a police scene in Mesa, Arizona. An officer carrying an AR-15 style rifle stood close to the auditors, and the auditors said his finger was near the trigger and that this felt intimidating. The officer said he was keeping distance because of an active situation, and he said there was an outstanding subject and that the situation was under control. The auditors repeatedly asked him to put the rifle away and to move back, and one asked for his badge number. The narrator then says citizens generally have a protected right to record police in public and that officers may justify tactical control near an active scene.

  • Minnesota deputies question man about license plate and registration at city hall lot

    Carver County Sheriff's Office · Carver County, MN

    Officers approached a man in a car parked in the Chanhassen City Hall lot, saying they had misread his plate and that it came back to a different vehicle. The man said a strap held the plate flat, and the officer cited a Minnesota rule against obstructing a plate. The man repeatedly asked if he was being detained and declined to give his middle name, while officers said Minnesota law required a full name. Officers also noted expired registration on his Washington plates and raised a welfare concern. The sergeant gave a verbal warning and the officers left.

  • Goodyear officers trespass auditors from post office and arrest one

    Goodyear Police Department · Goodyear, AZ

    The narrator states that in April 2019 in Goodyear, Arizona, a First Amendment audit at a post office turned into a dispute over trespass, public property and ID refusal. An officer told the auditors that the business was asking them to leave and that they were trespassed. The auditors said the building was public property and asked how they could be trespassed without a crime. An officer identified himself as Miller, and the badge number 1155 is heard after repeated requests. Officers asked for ID, an auditor declined, and one auditor was then handcuffed and arrested. The narrator notes that federal facilities like post offices can have specific conduct rules.

  • Niagara Falls officers question sign installer over reported burglary attempt

    Niagara Falls Police Department · Niagara Falls, NY

    Officers responded to a call about a possible burglary attempt at a business where a man was applying window signage or tint. The worker said he was working, asked why he was being detained, and declined to show ID unless lawfully detained. Officers said they were investigating, and the worker pointed to what he described as shifting explanations. Officers said they were trying to confirm he worked for the owner, and the worker repeatedly suggested they call the owner or the mayor. Officers eventually left after saying they could not reach the owner.

  • Olmos Park arrests and auditors' complaints of injury and force

    Olmos Park Police Department · Olmos Park, TX

    The narrator states that in March 2018 in Olmos Park, Texas, a police interaction turned chaotic, with arrests and allegations of excessive force. Auditors are heard saying a man was bleeding from a head injury and asking for an ambulance. They repeatedly asked what they were being arrested for and said no crime had been committed. One speaker said he was being detained on a warrant, and later auditors told an arriving SAPD officer to arrest the three officers. The narrator grades police C minus, citing questions about probable cause and the reasonableness of force.

  • Officers respond to open carry of rifle near Tyson Foods plant

    Wilkesboro Police Department · Wilkesboro, NC

    According to the narrator, employees at a Tyson Foods facility in Wilkesboro, North Carolina reported a man openly carrying a rifle while conducting a Second Amendment audit. Several officers responded. One officer told the man that carrying a rifle in this way could be going armed to the terror of the public, a misdemeanor. The man said he had checked state law and a land survey and was within the public easement, and he asked whether he was being detained. An officer answered that no detainment was going on. The encounter ended cordially, with the man thanking the officers and leaving.

  • Bexar County deputy talks with auditor at bus stop

    Bexar County Sheriff's Office · Bexar County, TX

    The narrator states that in May 2020 outside a bus stop in Bexar County, Texas, a deputy recognized a known First Amendment auditor. The deputy asked the man to step over for a moment. The man was initially reluctant, then the two had a calm conversation. The auditor said he would never interfere with deputies and noted that he was armed. The deputy said he had no concern about that, and the two discussed safety and the need to hear audio while recording. The encounter ended with no enforcement action shown.

  • Hillsborough County deputies and sergeant address auditor's distance during traffic stop investigation

    Hillsborough County Sheriff's Office · Hillsborough County, FL

    An auditor recording a deputy investigation in Hillsborough County, Florida, is told repeatedly to move back and "scoot back." He objects loudly that a deputy touched him, and says he is as far away as other bystanders. He later asks a sergeant about recording and privacy of computer screens. The sergeant says a camera behind officers can be a safety concern, and that nobody is blocking him from recording. The auditor asks to file a complaint against Deputy Ridgeway for touching him. The sergeant agrees to review her video. The auditor says he was previously arrested for obstruction, and he also alleges that deputies at a District 2 office touch people who record.

  • Man living in vehicle disputes citations with officers and declines to answer about complaint packet

    San Mateo Police Department · San Mateo, CA

    A man who the narrator says was living out of his vehicle told officers that citations, including for a bike light, were keeping him in homelessness. He named an Officer Chris Lewis and referred to San Mateo police, saying he had been cited over a stray dog that he said was not his. The officers offered a complaint packet, said they had places he could go if he accepted offers, and asked if he needed anything else. The man said he was not required to answer a question about the packet, and the officers ended the contact without escalation.

  • Peoria police sergeants answer auditor's questions in department lobby

    Peoria Police Department · Peoria, AZ

    Per the description, this encounter took place inside a Peoria, Arizona Police Department facility. An auditor filming in a public area tells officers he has questions that citizens asked him to bring. The two sergeants who identify themselves answer questions about staffing (about 200 sworn officers), the city's population, the end of participation in the DOD 1033 program, evidence handling and the meaning of 'peace officer.' The auditor accuses an officer of lying about whether a supervisor knew of the situation, and later says the officers are 'dismissed.' The officers are generally courteous. The narrator frames the legal question as the limits of filming inside a police facility.

  • Milton auditor detained and told he may be arrested to establish identity outside police department

    Milton Police Department · Milton, MA

    An auditor filming outside the Milton, Massachusetts police department disputes that he is in a restricted area. An officer tells him he is being detained for trespassing. He says there is no sign barring him and repeatedly asks if he is under arrest. An officer tells him, "if I have to arrest you to get your identity I will do it," and says she will charge him with trespassing if he does not leave. He walks away, and then asks a lieutenant to take a complaint about a sergeant. The lieutenant offers a complaint form and says the area beyond the fence has weapons. The narrator says refusing to identify generally does not give grounds for arrest in Massachusetts. It adds that the analysis changes if police already have probable cause for another offense such as trespass, and it cites Glik v. Cunniffe on the right to record.

  • Boca Raton officer explains solicitation ordinance to man with sign on sidewalk

    Boca Raton Police Department · Boca Raton, FL

    The narrator states a man was holding a cardboard sign on a public sidewalk in Boca Raton, Florida, and that security called police. Before police arrived, a security employee told the man he could not be on that side of the street, citing solicitation, and said authorities might be called. An officer then arrived, said the man was not doing anything wrong on the sidewalk, and read a local ordinance aloud, which the officer identified as section 16 3 as heard. The officer said approaching cars and taking items from people would be a violation and arrestable, but said he did not want to arrest the man. The encounter ended calmly with both parties wishing each other a good day.

  • Fisherman questions deputies after they run his license plate

    Charlotte County Sheriff's Office · Charlotte County, FL

    After the first encounter, the fisherman said deputies ran his plates, and he repeatedly asked a deputy why. The deputy repeatedly replied 'what can I do for you today' and 'have a nice day' without answering. The fisherman said he recorded deputy names, badge numbers, car numbers and plate numbers. He used profanity toward the deputies and later offered to buy a deputy a drink if he answered. A deputy said that offer could be bribery, and another told him to use official public records channels.

  • Broken Arrow officers respond to bank customer's call about men filming near ATM

    Broken Arrow Police Department · Broken Arrow, OK

    Two men filming from a public sidewalk outside a bank were confronted by a customer who said one of them filmed him at the ATM. The customer said he would call the police, and the men said they were recording in public. Officers arrived after the call, and an officer described the men as auditors. The officers said they could not make the men leave while they were on the sidewalk. They said they could trespass them or ask them to leave if they stepped onto bank property.

  • Mullica Township officers question parked man recording them over community complaint

    Mullica Township Police Department · Mullica Township, NJ

    A man records officers while sitting in his legally parked vehicle on a public street. The officers say they are responding to a call about people being concerned. They cite window tint and a U-turn, ask for ID, and say they could pull him out of the vehicle. The driver says he has no tint, asks what law he has violated, and asks whether refusing ID or questions would lead to arrest. An officer answers no and says he can sit there and record. The driver asks for a name and badge number, and an officer points to his badge, which the driver has trouble pronouncing.

  • Taylorville officers ask man on sidewalk near bank for ID after filming complaints

    Taylorville Police Department · Taylorville, IL

    Officers approached a man on a public sidewalk near a bank, saying they received complaints from citizens that he was video recording them and their cards or ATM use. An officer repeatedly asked for his ID or identification and said he wanted to identify him so he could inform his area. The man declined to provide ID, was not told he was under arrest, and asked about the officers' oath. An officer said they took an oath to the Taylorville Police Department. After a call with a supervisor, the encounter ended with the officers leaving, and the narrator says the transcript never clearly shows he was detained.

  • Alexandria officers question driver and passenger during failure-to-signal stop

    Alexandria Police Department · Alexandria, LA

    Per the description, Officers Jim Lewis and Samuel Terrell stopped a driver with a passenger in Alexandria, Louisiana, for an alleged failure to signal. The officers read Miranda-style warnings, questioned the occupants about drugs, relationships and residency, and asked the driver to empty his pockets, which he declined. The driver refused consent to search his vehicle, and an officer told the passenger she was not free to leave and that there is no phone use during traffic stops, citing a firearm in the vehicle. The description states the citations were later dismissed and the driver and passenger pursued a federal civil-rights lawsuit.

  • Manchester officers and Deputy Chief respond to filmed traffic stop with passenger dispute

    Manchester Police Department · Manchester, MO

    A cameraman recorded a traffic stop involving two of his employees near his job site. He and an officer argued about how far he must stand, with the officer citing a 10 foot distance. The cameraman repeatedly asked for a sergeant and objected to the passenger being asked to exit the vehicle and to a possible frisk or search, saying neither he nor the passenger consented. Officers said the cameraman was interfering and could have been avoided if the driver had given his license and insurance. Officers said a Deputy Chief was coming, and the video ends before the outcome is shown.

  • Lewis County sergeant questions auditor filming jail sally port and declines to give name first

    Lewis County Sheriff's Office · Lewis County, NY

    An auditor filmed construction near the sally port at the Lewis County Correctional Facility. A sergeant came out, asked why he was filming, and called for a patrol unit. The auditor asked for the sergeant's name and said he would not give his own reason until he was identified, and a second sergeant then declined to identify himself unless told what was going on. The auditor was not detained. A deputy said the Sheriff's policy does not require identifying oneself to the public and said he would look into it. The narrator discusses First Amendment protections for recording and the role of agency policy in identification.

  • Freeport police sergeant confronts auditor filming inside Village Hall

    Freeport Village Police Department · Freeport Village, NY

    A man recording inside Freeport Village Hall is approached by a police sergeant who, per the transcript, tells him he is causing a disturbance and asks him to go outside. The auditor says he is exercising a First Amendment right, declines to leave, and refuses to show ID, asking whether the sergeant has reasonable articulable suspicion of a crime. The sergeant says a building policy applies and at one point tells him he is free to leave, then tells him not to 'do anything stupid' as the auditor stays. A deputy chief arrives, and the auditor asks him to instruct the sergeant that he is not breaking any laws. The narrator notes that recording is protected subject to reasonable time, place and manner limits.

  • Pasco officer and pedestrian dispute walking in roadway and ID request

    Pasco Police Department · Pasco, WA

    An officer told a man recording to get out of the road and onto the sidewalk. The man disputed that the command was lawful, asked for the officer's name, badge number and a business card, and refused to give his own ID. He repeatedly asserted Fourth Amendment claims. An officer identified himself as Guard or Guards of the Pasco Police Department, and the encounter ended without an arrest shown. The narrator says the officers had a plausible basis under Washington roadway law and that some of the citizen's claims were too broad.

  • Hamburg officer detains auditor near Lackawanna line and demands ID

    Hamburg Town Police Department · Hamburg Town, NY

    A citizen recording an officer questioned whether the Hamburg officer was operating outside his jurisdiction near Lackawanna. The officer asked for ID, the citizen said he did not have to provide it and asked what crime he was suspected of, and the officer said he did not need a crime to detain him and cited a violation (walking in the road, later parking on the curb). The citizen was handcuffed after, he says, reaching toward his car for ID. The officer later removed the handcuffs, said he would cite him for parking, and cited a New York provision allowing violations to be written within 100 yards of the jurisdiction line. The citizen called the ticket retaliatory.

  • Fort Walton Beach officers address bank photography complaint and ID refusal

    Fort Walton Beach Police Department · Fort Walton Beach, FL

    Officers responded to a bank where a man was photographing from a public sidewalk after staff complained. The first officer told him he was within his rights to film, said he could not be forced to identify since no crime was committed, and said he had been told not to go onto the bank's property. Officers gave names and badge numbers when asked. In conversation with a bank manager, an officer said the man was doing nothing illegal but called it creepy and bad manners. Officers also said to him that the bank people were paranoid, and one told him not to block the sidewalk, which he objected to as an unnecessary directive. A lieutenant later told him he was exercising constitutional rights and the officers left.

  • Lower Southampton sergeant ends contact after man invokes Fifth Amendment

    Lower Southampton Township Police Department · Lower Southampton Township, PA

    The narrator states that in February 2024 officers responded to multiple complaints about a man standing near local businesses. A sergeant approached and said they had a couple of calls that he was there today and yesterday, and asked whether he had business in the area. The man asked if he had to answer questions, then said he was invoking his Fifth Amendment right to remain silent. The sergeant confirmed he did not want to answer questions, then said have a good day and left.

  • York County deputies demand ID from auditor over private property dispute

    York County Sheriff's Office · York County, SC

    York County deputies in Fort Mill first said that filming from the public area was lawful. After a property occupant objected, a deputy said he needed the auditor's ID in order to trespass him, and confirmed the auditor was being detained and could not leave the property. The auditor stepped onto public property, and the deputy continued to ask for ID, saying the trespass notice could not be entered without it. The auditor declined to identify himself, said he would give ID only under threat of arrest, and said he would file a complaint. A supervisor arrived and told the auditor that if he did not want to identify himself he should not go back onto the property.

  • Universal City sergeant confronts man recording a vehicle search

    Universal City Police Department · Universal City, TX

    A man recording police search a car on private property was told by a sergeant to give them space and step back 10 feet. The man said he was not interfering and cited the First Amendment. The sergeant said he was standing close and asked about his pockets, then began reading him Miranda rights, according to the transcript. The man said he would step back five feet. A second officer later spoke more calmly, and the man thanked the department for being professional.

  • Santa Ana officers order auditor to back up at blocked-road scene

    Santa Ana Police Department · Santa Ana, CA

    The narrator states that on July 1 a First Amendment auditor filmed a heavy police response at a blocked road in Santa Ana. Officers told him to back up and stay behind a line, and one officer said he was impeding an investigation. The auditor said no tape was in place, and an officer later said they were putting tape up. The auditor said an officer pushed him back and asked for a sergeant to file a use-of-force complaint. A corporal took the complaint, and the auditor said the push was not gentle and declined to give some personal contact details.

  • LAPD officer orders filmer out of claimed crime scene near reported stolen vehicle

    Los Angeles Police Department · Los Angeles, CA

    The narrator states this occurred in August 2018 in Los Angeles, California. An officer told a man filming that he was inside a crime scene because a nearby vehicle was reported stolen, and repeatedly told him to leave. The filmer moved away and said other officers had not told him about any crime scene. The officer said he would cite the man for being in the street and later gave a name and number when asked. The filmer used profanity and insults toward the officer, and the officer made some sarcastic and hostile remarks in return. When asked about his department, the officer said Los Angeles Police Department.

  • Hammond City Hall staff call police over citizen recording inside building

    Hammond Police Department · Hammond, IN

    According to the narrator, in September 2025 an independent auditor entered Hammond City Hall in Indiana to record government operations. Employees declined to speak while being recorded, a security employee asked him to leave citing complaints, and police were called. The auditor said recording in public areas is a protected right and that no crime was occurring. A sergeant and a captain arrived, and the auditor explained his position and asked them to educate the staff. The officers did not order him to stop or leave in the portion transcribed, and the auditor declined to give his own name when asked.

  • Long Beach officers detain auditor after he approaches patrol car window

    Long Beach Police Department · Long Beach, CA

    A first amendment auditor in Long Beach, California, says he walked to an officer's window to ask for a name and badge number during a traffic stop. The officer said the auditor was standing in the roadway and told him he was being detained. The auditor repeatedly asked for a supervisor and asked what law he had broken. The auditor says the officer told him he would be arrested for failure to identify and that he was being cited. A second officer gave his name and badge number as Officer Leon, 12050, and said a sergeant was coming.

  • Franklin County deputy tells auditor filming from public area is lawful

    Franklin County Sheriff's Office · Franklin County, WA

    A deputy identifying with a county sheriff's office contacted an auditor who was filming near a building after a caller reported a suspicious person. The deputy said the auditor was within his rights as long as he was not on the property and that filming from a public area is lawful. The deputy said he would go inside and ask whether the occupants wanted the auditor trespassed. The auditor objected that this amounted to soliciting a trespass. The narrator adds commentary about Washington RCW 46.61.021 and ID requirements in traffic stops.

  • Deputy detains and searches passenger during expired-tag traffic stop, per bystander

    Los Angeles County Sheriff's Office · Los Angeles County, CA

    A traffic stop reportedly for expired registration tags shifts toward the passenger, who is asked to step out and is patted down. A bystander recording says passengers need not identify themselves and should not consent to searches. He says the deputy went into the passenger's pockets instead of doing an outside pat down. A second deputy arrives to check on the partner. The recorder questions him about backup, passenger rights, and officer safety, and asks for his name and badge number, and the deputy gives them. Neither the stop nor the search is shown in the transcript.

  • Airway Heights officers respond to wastewater facility sign-in complaint and speak calmly with journalist

    Airway Heights Police Department · Airway Heights, WA

    Officers responded after facility staff at a public wastewater plant reported that a visitor had not signed in. The visitor, who was recording and described himself as a journalist working on an ecology story, said he was uneasy about signing in, mentioned using a pen name, and worried staff would close the gate and stop his reporting. The officers said the facility wanted everyone to sign in, that a sign on the main door requires it, and that they were not identifying him or removing him. One officer offered to speak with staff so he could leave after signing in, and they agreed to check with the facility first. The narrator says the officers de-escalated and the facility staff ultimately cooperated.

  • Gainesville officers respond to postal employee complaint about woman filming in post office lobby

    Gainesville Police Department · Gainesville, GA

    Postal employees called police about a woman who said she was an independent journalist and was filming in a post office lobby. Employees said customers were uncomfortable and cited privacy concerns about PIN entry. The woman cited the postal rule on photography (Poster 7, 39 CFR 232.1), disputed that she could be removed, and asked for officer names and badge numbers. An officer said he did not want to remove her without a clear basis and waited for a manager. Officers on scene discussed among themselves that she was not committing a crime and that it was a gray area, and they did not make her leave. The narrator's closing commentary says the officers slowed the encounter, read the rule, consulted supervision and identified no crime.

  • Madison County deputies and staff question filmer outside sheriff's facility fence

    Madison County Sheriff's Office · Madison County, NC

    The narrator states a citizen journalist was recording patrol vehicles at the Madison County Sheriff's Department in North Carolina for a story on marked and unmarked police cars. Staff, including a woman who said she was sworn with the sheriff's office, asked what he was doing and said they investigate suspicious activity near a secured facility. The filmer said he stayed in public areas up to the fence, asked whether suspicion is a crime, and said he was not required to give his reason or ID. The staff member asked for his ID and said she was sworn, and he refused. The encounter ended with him saying he would continue recording.

  • Pennsylvania troopers dispute filming toward restricted workspace in Lancaster barracks lobby

    State Police · Unmapped County, PA

    A citizen filming in the public lobby of Pennsylvania State Police Troop J headquarters said he was making a right-to-know request. Troopers told him he could record in the lobby but not into a partitioned dispatch or secure workspace, citing confidential information. The citizen said anything visible from a public area could be recorded and that troopers should create privacy, for example by tinting windows. A sergeant and a lieutenant repeated the restriction and the citizen asked for names. The narrator says troopers eventually acknowledged the lobby recording right, while the citizen overstated how far it extends into restricted spaces.

  • Stratford officers ask lawfully parked driver to leave after neighbor complaint

    Stratford Police Department · Stratford, NJ

    The narrator states a man parked legally on a public street in Stratford, New Jersey while visiting a friend, and police approached after a neighbor reported an unfamiliar vehicle. The officer said the caller described tinted windows and was concerned, and asked the driver whether he would mind leaving because it made someone uncomfortable. The driver said discomfort is not against the law, declined to explain his reason for being there, and declined to leave. The officer acknowledged the driver was not breaking the law, said he would tell the caller the driver was legally parked, and the two parted on cordial terms.

  • Centennial deputy requests ID from man parking and walking dog in Denver area

    Arapahoe County Sheriff's Office · Arapahoe County, CO

    The narrator states a deputy followed a citizen who had parked and was walking his dog, then asked for identification. The deputy gave his name as heard 'Mike Stokes' with a sheriff's office, badge 8716, and said he was trying to figure out what was going on. The citizen declined to give his name, saying he was not suspected of a crime, and argued that Colorado law requires reasonable suspicion before ID can be required. The deputy said the citizen was obligated to identify himself, and the citizen disagreed and asked for a supervisor. The clip ends with the deputy calling for a supervisor and no arrest is shown.

  • Jacksonville officers detain photographer near Naval Station Mayport over ID refusal

    Jacksonville Sheriff's Office · Duval County, FL

    A man photographing and recording near Naval Station Mayport was approached by officers responding to a call about suspicious photographing of people leaving the base. An officer said the activity 'may not be unlawful but it's highly suspicious' and repeatedly asked for ID. The photographer said he was on public right of way, asked whether he was detained, and declined to show ID. An officer eventually said he was being detained and that failing to give ID was a crime, which the photographer disputed. The photographer invoked his right to remain silent and asked for a supervisor, who was said to be on the way.

  • Henderson County deputies question photographer in courthouse lobby

    Henderson County Sheriff's Office · Henderson County, NC

    A photographer filming inside a public courthouse lobby was questioned by deputies who asked for identification and his purpose. The deputies said his activity appeared suspicious and referred to the secure building and security screening. The citizen repeatedly asked what crime he had committed, said he was engaged in First Amendment protected activity, and declined to provide ID. The narrator states the courthouse is in North Carolina; the video does not show how the encounter ended beyond an officer ending the conversation.

  • Fountain officers detain cameraman said to resemble wanted suspect

    Fountain Police Department · Fountain, CO

    The narrator states a man began recording at a residential property in Fountain, Colorado after police responded to an earlier incident at a friend's home. An officer said police were looking for someone the man closely resembled, who had a felony warrant, and showed a photo while asking him to identify himself. The cameraman declined to answer questions or give his name. The video then goes black, and a bystander states that the man was taken into custody for failing to identify himself and that he was not the wanted person. The narrator cites Terry v. Ohio and a Colorado statute on identification, and raises the question of whether the force lasted longer than necessary.

  • Cincinnati officers ask man for name and date of birth over suspect description near Subway

    Cincinnati Police Department · Cincinnati, OH

    Officers ask a man for his name and date of birth, saying he matches a suspect description near a Subway. The man repeatedly declines to identify himself, says he did nothing wrong, and tells officers to check surveillance video. An officer says that if he can confirm the man is not the suspect through the video, he will leave. An officer is heard reading the description as a hooded Black male of average build. The officers conclude the man is not the person they want and end the contact, and the man tells them to have a good night.

  • Senatobia officers detain two people recording from sidewalk and demand ID

    Senatobia Police Department · Senatobia, MS

    Officers stopped two people who were recording from a public sidewalk and told them they were detained, citing a call about two people walking around a bank and recording license plates. The citizens repeatedly asked what crime was being investigated and said they had not been inside a bank. An officer said there was an active investigation and a call matching their clothing. A lieutenant said, "Give me your ID or I will place you under arrest," and said that during an investigation in Mississippi he has a right to ask for ID. The citizens cited the Fourth Amendment, and the description says they were later told they were free to go and filed a complaint at the police department.

  • NYPD officers restrict photographer's access to area outside precinct

    New York City Police Department · New York City, NY

    A man taking pictures of lockers in an area at or near an NYPD precinct was told by officers and a sergeant that he was not allowed to walk down a certain path. He repeatedly asked whether he was being detained, and an officer said he was not detained. Officers said the area was department property, while he said it was publicly accessible and asked what crime was being committed. Officers did not give a reason he considered clear, and later told him he had been asked to leave. He requested a complaint form from the desk sergeant, and the narrator then discusses the legal questions.

  • Deputies and sergeant question auditor filming near Sheriff's Office and warn of trespass arrest

    Jacksonville Police Department · Jacksonville, TX

    The narrator states that in 2023 a First Amendment auditor near a sheriff's office in Jacksonville, Texas was confronted after filming in public, following a suspicious person call. Officers are heard asking for his name and ID, patting him down for safety, per the auditor's complaint, and saying they were investigating a call. One officer identifies himself as 'Sergeant wild' (as heard). The auditor repeatedly asks whether he is detained and says he is on a sidewalk. Officers tell him to leave and say that if he returns to the Sheriff's Office property, including the parking lot, he will be arrested for criminal trespass. The auditor disputes that the facility is private property.

  • Utica officers respond to complaint about two people recording, dispute over ID and detention

    Utica Police Department · Utica, MI

    The narrator states this encounter takes place in Utica, Michigan, after police responded to a complaint about two citizens recording in public. The citizens told an officer to go talk to the person who called, and they objected when an officer touched or closed their vehicle hood. They repeatedly asked why they were being detained and refused to answer questions. They also asked the officer to identify himself. The officer refused to give his ID number, and the citizens swore at and insulted the officers throughout. The officers told one person to back up, and one citizen said he would file complaints. The footage ends without a stated resolution.

  • Brevard officers respond to complaint about auditor filming at oil company while openly carrying

    Brevard Police Department · Brevard, NC

    The narrator states an auditor was recording the Henderson Oil Company facility in Brevard, North Carolina, from what he describes as a public area while openly carrying a firearm. Employees reportedly objected to the filming and the gun and called police. An officer asked the auditor for his name and said he needed to know who the auditor was, and the auditor refused and said the employees had the information. A lieutenant, whose name was heard as Cat Raxter, then spoke with another person, said the call was about someone videoing on the corner, and told them they were in a public space. The encounter ended with the officers saying they hoped the auditor had a good day.

  • Officers tell auditors they cannot film Marine Corps Reserve facility in Pasadena

    Pasadena Police Department · Pasadena, CA

    A First Amendment auditor was filming outside a U.S. Marine Corps Reserve facility in Pasadena, California, according to the description. An officer approached and said the auditors could not videotape and could not be on the property. The auditors replied that they were not on the property and asked the officer to show video of it. An officer said the facility's occupants did not want to be filmed, and the auditors asked for names and badge numbers. A second officer later said filming a federal facility was not allowed, and the auditors said the First Amendment protects filming anything in public view.

  • Moorpark officers ask auditors for ID while they photograph police service center

    Ventura County Sheriff's Office · Ventura County, CA

    The narrator states that in October 2018, outside the Moorpark Police Service Center in California, a First Amendment audit turned into a discussion about ID refusal and public photography. An officer asks for the auditor's ID and questions him about probation and parole, which the auditor says is none of his business. The officers say they received calls about the group in the parking lot and that people are suspicious. One officer says he works for the Ventura County sheriff. The officers repeatedly tell the group they are dismissed, and the auditors say they are lawfully photographing and have not committed a crime. The encounter ends without an arrest.

  • Manchester officers order auditor to leave state agency lobby

    Manchester Police Department · Manchester, NH

    The narrator states that in November 2022 a First Amendment auditor entered a state Department of Health and Human Services building in Manchester, New Hampshire. The narrator says employees accused him of violating HIPAA and police were called. Officers told him employees did not want him there and gave what they called a lawful order to leave, saying he would be arrested for criminal trespass or disorderly conduct if he stayed. The auditor said the lobby is public, asked for a supervisor, and said he would accept arrest rather than leave. Officers physically blocked the doorway, and the video's analysis says HIPAA generally applies to healthcare providers.

  • Police and refinery security tell man filming from sidewalk to leave or face obstruction charge

    Paulsboro Police Department · Paulsboro, NJ

    A man filming near a PBF Energy refinery was approached by an Allied Universal security guard who said he could not film the plant, and the man said he was on a public sidewalk. Police arrived, and an officer asked for his full name. The man declined and repeatedly asked whether he was detained. An officer told him he was free to go but must leave the area or be arrested for obstruction, and said it was a Homeland Security site. A second officer later told him he was trespassing and to get off the property, while the man said he was on a public sidewalk. The narrator says the property line was not clearly established.

  • Montpelier state building staff require security escort for auditors filming lobbies and ask them to leave

    Montpelier Police Department · Montpelier, VT

    Two auditors filmed inside a government building in Montpelier, Vermont, and were accompanied by security. They objected to being escorted. A deputy secretary said the office holds confidential information in employee workspaces, and the auditors said lobbies are public and that they pay for the building. Later an official said they could be asked to leave if they disturbed employees by questioning them. When one auditor asked if this was a lawful order, the official said he was asking them to leave or he would call the police. The auditors then stepped outside, saying they would call the police themselves. The narrator says public forum doctrine allows different levels of protection depending on a property's designated use.

  • Montgomery County constable stops driver after middle finger gesture, K-9 does not alert

    Montgomery County Constable: Precinct 4 · Montgomery County, TX

    On Needham Road in Porter, Texas, a driver said he raised his middle finger at a constable precinct officer who then turned around and stopped him. The officer said he saw a traffic violation, and the citation was for failing to signal a distance before a turn. The driver declined to answer personal questions and denied consent to search. A deputy with a narcotics detection canine walked the dog around the vehicle, and said the dog did not alert. The driver was issued a citation with a court date and said he would contest it.

  • Colorado Springs officers respond to dispensary complaint about person filmingAlso covered

    Colorado Springs Police Department · Colorado Springs, CO

    A man filming from a sidewalk near the High Tops dispensary says he is on a public right of way and not on the property. Dispensary employees asked him to leave, saying customers were uncomfortable and that he was following people. The employees called police. Officer Rodriguez arrived, gave a CAD number and business card, said the call concerned a disagreement over whether the man was leaving the property, and said a supervisor would clarify. A supervisor who gave his surname as Fudge and a number of 3171 then spoke with the man, asked about his purpose, and advised him to be careful around upset customers. No citation or arrest is shown, and the man stayed where he was as the officers left.

  • Brimfield sergeant asks auditor for ID during consensual contact outside dispensaryAlso covered

    Brimfield Police Department · Brimfield, MA

    A sergeant responded to a reported complaint about a man filming outside a cannabis dispensary in Brimfield, Massachusetts. The sergeant asked for the auditor's ID and the reason for his presence, saying people had called to complain. The auditor asked for a CAD number, which the sergeant said had not been assigned yet, and asked whether he was being detained. The sergeant said the conversation was consensual, the auditor ended it, and the sergeant said state police were on the way. Later the sergeant gave a CAD number (as heard, 25-64 612) and said it appeared generated at 12:54.

  • Panama City officers respond to restaurant manager's complaint about sidewalk sign holderAlso covered

    Panama City Police Department · Panama City, FL

    A man holding a cardboard sign asking for prayers for homeless veterans stood on a public sidewalk at Bay View and 10th Street in Panama City, Florida. A restaurant manager or owner told him not to stand in front of her business and said she would call police. An officer identified as Durham arrived, told the man he was not on the restaurant's property and that there was nothing he could do, and said the sign was not unlawful. The officer then spoke with the manager. A second officer, addressed as Officer Brand, later told the man he could not loiter in front of a business if asked to leave, which the man disputed. The man remained on the sidewalk and the officers left without any recorded enforcement.

Departments involved (173)

Officers named (4)

CopFax documents incidents from Tyrant Cop Files's publicly available videos, with 220 incidents reviewed and published so far. Each incident page embeds the original video and credits the creator.

Get listed: creators can ask CopFax to document their channel.

CopFax lists independent creators who cover police and civil-rights topics. Their views are their own, and listing a channel isn't an endorsement.

Report an error