First Amendment audit, detention for trespass, ID demand
Milton auditor detained and told he may be arrested to establish identity outside police department
Department Accountability Report
- Location
- Outside the Milton police department building, near a fence and wooded rear area
- Department
- Milton Police Department
- Rights involved
- First Amendment, Fourth Amendment
- Outcome
- The auditor leaves the area without being arrested. A lieutenant offers him a complaint form. The narrator grades police C minus and the citizen B minus.
Summary
An auditor filming outside the Milton, Massachusetts police department disputes that he is in a restricted area. An officer tells him he is being detained for trespassing. He says there is no sign barring him and repeatedly asks if he is under arrest. An officer tells him, "if I have to arrest you to get your identity I will do it," and says she will charge him with trespassing if he does not leave. He walks away, and then asks a lieutenant to take a complaint about a sergeant. The lieutenant offers a complaint form and says the area beyond the fence has weapons. The narrator says refusing to identify generally does not give grounds for arrest in Massachusetts. It adds that the analysis changes if police already have probable cause for another offense such as trespass, and it cites Glik v. Cunniffe on the right to record.
CopFax assessment (opinion)
How police handled it
Not yet assessed
This is CopFax's opinion based on the source video and records linked on this page. The factual summary above is separate from this assessment.
Officers involved
No officers identified yet.
Related public records
No public records linked yet.