Traffic stop passenger ID dispute
Haverhill officers obtain passenger's name during traffic stop and are questioned by auditors
Department Accountability Report
- Location
- Roadside traffic stop, Haverhill, Massachusetts per video description
- Department
- Haverhill Police Department
- Rights involved
- Fourth Amendment
- Outcome
- No arrest is shown for the passenger. The auditors leave after disputing the officers' practices. The narrator rates the officers B minus and the auditor C+.
Summary
After a traffic stop, auditors observe officers obtaining a passenger's identification or name. They confront the officers, saying police need reasonable articulable suspicion to ask a passenger for ID. An officer says the Supreme Court has ruled that officers are allowed to ask. The auditors say the passenger did not know his rights and gave his ID. The officer says the passenger gave it voluntarily, and the discussion becomes heated. An officer gives his name and badge number on request. The narrator's closing analysis says asking is not necessarily a violation but compelling ID normally needs a legal basis.
CopFax assessment (opinion)
How police handled it
Not yet assessed
This is CopFax's opinion based on the source video and records linked on this page. The factual summary above is separate from this assessment.
Officers involved
No officers identified yet.
Related public records
No public records linked yet.