First Amendment audit, ID request during call about recording
Valparaiso officer ends ID demand during call about filming at COVID-19 testing site
Department Accountability Report
- Location
- Sidewalk outside a COVID-19 testing site
- Department
- Valparaiso Police Department
- Rights involved
- First Amendment, Fourth Amendment
- Outcome
- The officer told the auditor he was free to film from public property. The auditor was not identified, and the encounter ended without enforcement.
Summary
Staff at a COVID-19 testing site tell an auditor that filming patients from the sidewalk is a HIPAA violation and on private property, and say they will call police. The officer says the auditor is allowed to film from public property and should stay off the property. He asks for ID and says people involved in a police call are compelled to ID. The auditor refuses and says reasonable articulable suspicion of a crime is required. The officer says he would identify the auditor if staff said he was on their property. After the auditor says he stayed on the sidewalk and offers video proof, the officer says he is fine and leaves.
CopFax assessment (opinion)
How police handled it
Not yet assessed
This is CopFax's opinion based on the source video and records linked on this page. The factual summary above is separate from this assessment.
Officers involved
No officers identified yet.
Related public records
No public records linked yet.