Skip to content

First Amendment sign-holding; criminal trespass warning and ID demand

Carthage police criminally trespass man holding sign at city hall and demand ID

Email this report

Department Accountability Report

Citizen videoHonorYourOath Civil Rights Investigations YouTube profile pictureSource video: HonorYourOath Civil Rights Investigations (opens in a new tab) (CopFax creator page) · Watch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)
Date
September 20, 2024
Location
Steps and front door of Carthage City Hall
Department
Carthage Police Department
Rights involved
First Amendment, Fourth Amendment
Outcome
The man was issued a criminal trespass notice and left. Per the demand letter, the city manager later apologized, removed the trespass designation, and committed to additional civil rights training. The video also presents a 2026 demand letter seeking $25,000 and other terms.

Summary

A man holding a sign reading "God bless the homeless vets" at the steps of Carthage City Hall was approached by an officer after city staff reportedly said they were nervous and did not want him near the door. The officer said the man could move near the road or be criminally trespassed. The man said he believed he had a right to be there and asked whether he had to provide ID. The officer said he had to log the trespass with dispatch, told the man he was "absolutely" being detained and required to give ID, and said he would go to jail if he refused. The man gave ID, was told he was free to go but must stay off the property, and was directed to contact the city manager about an appeal.

CopFax assessment (opinion)

How police handled it

Not yet assessed

This is CopFax's opinion based on the source video and records linked on this page. The factual summary above is separate from this assessment.

Officers involved

No officers identified yet.

Related public records

No public records linked yet.

Report an error