Not Specified
New York City, NY
Departments
Incidents
- NYPD officer tells cameraman he cannot record inside a police vehicle in Harlem
June 20, 2023 · New York City Police Department · New York City, NY
The narrator states that on June 20, 2023, on 125th Street in Harlem, an officer told a cameraman he could not record what was inside a city vehicle. The officer said it was a crime because the windows are tinted, but when asked whether it was a misdemeanor or felony, he told the cameraman to look it up. The cameraman asked whether he was being detained, and the officer said he was free to go. The cameraman then said the officer touched him and moved him, and the officer said he was not blocking movement. The cameraman said he was told he was not in handcuffs because it was not a crime, and the narrator notes the officer made no arrest.
- NYPD officers search pedestrian on Flatbush Avenue, knock phone from his hand
November 28, 2021 · New York City Police Department · New York City, NY
The narrator states that on November 28, 2021, three 70th Precinct officers got out of an unmarked vehicle and searched a pedestrian on Flatbush Avenue. The officers said they were making a lawful arrest after a field intelligence officer reported a hand-to-hand drug transaction. The pedestrian said he was only walking and was not involved in any crime. Body camera footage shows one officer grabbing the pedestrian's groin area, and another officer knocking the pedestrian's phone to the ground and telling him he could not photograph officers. The three officers left without making an arrest, and then returned after the pedestrian called 911 for an ambulance. The sergeant spoke with him alone, and the pedestrian declined to give information or make a complaint to him.
- NYPD officers restrict photographer's access to area outside precinct
New York City Police Department · New York City, NY
A man taking pictures of lockers in an area at or near an NYPD precinct was told by officers and a sergeant that he was not allowed to walk down a certain path. He repeatedly asked whether he was being detained, and an officer said he was not detained. Officers said the area was department property, while he said it was publicly accessible and asked what crime was being committed. Officers did not give a reason he considered clear, and later told him he had been asked to leave. He requested a complaint form from the desk sergeant, and the narrator then discusses the legal questions.
- NYPD officers cite department policy when auditor films inside police facility
New York City Police Department · New York City, NY
An auditor filming at a police facility asks officers to cite a law that prohibits recording in a public building. Officers say it is department policy and that they were instructed to refer the matter to their legal department. The auditor repeatedly says officers enforce laws, not policy, and asks them to identify themselves and provide a complaint form. Several additional officers arrive, and one officer says he is trying to be professional and offers a business card. The narrator says the debate centers on whether an internal policy can restrict a constitutional activity.
- NYPD officers confront armed woman in Times Square; shooting follows
New York City Police Department · New York City, NY
The description states a woman had stabbed two civilians on 7th Avenue before encountering Transit patrol officers near West 42nd Street. In the footage, officers repeatedly tell her to put the knife down and drop it while trying to talk with her. Per the transcript, she says she is tired of the world, tells officers to "come and get me," and says they will have to kill her. Officers respond that they do not want to hurt her and tell her to breathe. The description states that Tasers were deployed without effect, after which one officer fired one round and another fired two rounds, and the woman was later pronounced deceased at a hospital. The shooting itself is not clearly audible in the transcript.
- Journalists reportedly denied entry to police-organized event on NYC City Hall steps
New York City Police Department · New York City, NY
A guest, described by the host as an independent journalist, says he and two other creators were not allowed into a public event on the City Hall steps in New York City, which was organized by police unions to discuss people they called social media agitators. He states officers told them they lacked proper press credentials, and that the NYPD issues such credentials. He claims a taller man in a suit pushed him back without identifying himself, and that a detective elbowed him and then denied it. He says his 360 degree camera recorded the contact. This account is the guest's description in a livestream discussion; the footage itself is not shown in this video.
- NYPD officers question photographer outside facility and say he is not free to go
New York City Police Department · New York City, NY
A man photographing police vehicles near an NYPD facility in New York City is stopped by officers who say he is acting suspiciously. He repeatedly asks whether he is detained or free to go, what crime is being investigated, and whether he must answer questions. Officers say they are investigating and asking questions, and one says that looking inside police vehicles could be criminal mischief. The man says he is recording police activity in public, asks for a business card and a CCRB complaint form, and says he will not answer questions. The narrator then discusses Terry v. Ohio and says the key issue is what specific facts justified restricting his freedom.
- NYPD officer and auditor dispute recording and ID request outside precinct
New York City Police Department · New York City, NY
An auditor recording outside an NYPD precinct is approached by an officer who asks for ID, citing an apparent open container. The auditor says the container is a 0% alcohol beverage and asks what crime is suspected. The officer says the auditor is too close to the precinct and cannot film inside police cars, and the auditor says he is on a public sidewalk. The two exchange insults and repeated accusations of touching and crowding, and the auditor repeatedly asks for the officer's card and a sergeant. The officer tells the auditor to see his shield number and says he will stay at the scene.
- NYPD officers respond to cameraman's complaint about intoxicated man on Brooklyn sidewalk
New York City Police Department · New York City, NY
A cameraman recording from a public sidewalk in Bensonhurst, Brooklyn, says an intoxicated man approached him and grabbed his arm twice. He demands that the man be arrested and asks for a sergeant and for body cameras to be on. Officers say they did not witness harassment, that a summons requires an officer to observe the violation, and that officers have discretion. One officer says grabbing is not assault unless there is injury and calls it harassment, which is a violation. Officers say the cameraman may keep recording and that nobody told him he could not record. They say they called an ambulance for the intoxicated man.
- NYPD officers tell person to stop recording inside parked patrol car
New York City Police Department · New York City, NY
A person filming a parked NYPD vehicle is approached by officers who ask if he needs help. A female officer tells him to stop recording the vehicle's interior. The filmer asks if he is detained and says he can record anything visible from a public place. The officers say he is not detained, that they were checking on him, and that no one told him to stop recording in general. A male officer gives his name and badge number and the female officer later gives the filmer a card. The male officer says the filmer is free to exercise his rights but should not damage the vehicle, or he would be arrested.
- NYC officers arrest man over alleged open container and ID dispute
New York City Police Department · New York City, NY
A man standing near a vehicle is approached by officers who ask why he was looking inside it and tell him he has an open container. The man repeatedly says he does not drink alcohol, asks what crime or violation is alleged, and demands a body camera and a sergeant. An officer says he was lawfully stopped for an open container of alcohol and asks for ID, and the man refuses and asks for probable cause. Officers say "you're under arrest" and attempt to take him inside, while the man tells them not to touch him. The narrator says the officers appear to rely on an alleged open container violation and that whether legal standards were met is a central question.