Skip to content

Traffic stop; civil infraction contested hearing

Michigan magistrate dismisses speed and failure-to-yield citations after contested hearing

Email this report

Department Accountability Report

CommentaryAudit the Audit YouTube profile pictureSource video: Audit the Audit (opens in a new tab) (CopFax creator page) · Watch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)
Date
March 18, 2025
Location
Westbound 116th Avenue, Watson Township, turning onto 19th Street; hearing in Alagan County 57th District Court by Zoom
Department
Allegan County Sheriff's Office
Rights involved
Fourth Amendment, First Amendment
Outcome
Magistrate found the driver not responsible and dismissed both citations.

Summary

A deputy of the Alagan County Sheriff's Office issued a driver citations for too fast for conditions and failure to yield to an emergency vehicle. At a March 18, 2025 Zoom hearing, the deputy testified he paced the vehicle at 58 mph in a 55 zone and that the driver continued about a quarter mile before stopping. The driver said he had made a rude gesture at the deputy earlier and believed he was targeted, and that he turned onto a safer road. The magistrate found neither citation was a violation as written and found the driver not responsible. The narrator adds that under Whren, Nieves and Wesby the stop would likely still be lawful and a retaliation claim unlikely to succeed.

CopFax assessment (opinion)

How police handled it

Not yet assessed

This is CopFax's opinion based on the source video and records linked on this page. The factual summary above is separate from this assessment.

Officers involved

No officers identified yet.

Related public records

No public records linked yet.

Report an error