Skip to content

Anonymous noise/argument call; demand for identification; arrest and use of force

Melbourne officers arrest man for not identifying during loud-argument call, rib fractured

Email this report

Department Accountability Report

CommentaryAudit the Audit YouTube profile pictureSource video: Audit the Audit (opens in a new tab) (CopFax creator page) · Watch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)
Date
March 15, 2024
Location
Outside a residence in Melbourne, Florida
Department
Melbourne Police Department
Rights involved
Fourth Amendment
Outcome
Man taken to hospital (fractured rib, leg lacerations), then jailed on two counts of resisting without violence; charges dropped April 12, 2024. Internal review found no reasonable suspicion or probable cause; Officers Proctor and Gould each received a six-hour unpaid suspension and training duties. Narrator states the man filed a pro se federal lawsuit on March 12, 2026, still pending.

Summary

The narrator states Melbourne Police received an anonymous call on March 15, 2024 about a male and female arguing loudly at a home. Two officers found the resident standing outside alone, and the woman inside also spoke with them. On body camera, officers repeatedly asked the man for ID, said he could be arrested for refusing to identify during a criminal investigation, and then took him to the ground when he declined. The officers said he was reaching for his waistband; the narrator says this cannot be confirmed from the footage. One officer delivered knee strikes that fractured a rib, and the man's ID was later found in his pocket.

CopFax assessment (opinion)

How police handled it

Not yet assessed

This is CopFax's opinion based on the source video and records linked on this page. The factual summary above is separate from this assessment.

Officers involved

No officers identified yet.

Related public records

No public records linked yet.

Report an error