Fire lane parking citation and disorderly conduct arrest
Orange City officer cites driver for fire lane parking, then arrests him for disorderly conduct
Department Accountability Report
- Date
- October 8, 2023
- Location
- Publix grocery store parking lot, in front of the building, in a fire lane
- Department
- Orange City Police Department
- Rights involved
- First Amendment, Fourth Amendment
- Outcome
- Driver cited for parking, window tint and no proof of insurance, arrested for disorderly conduct, given a notice to appear and released on his own recognizance. Per the narrator, he entered a deferred prosecution agreement (anger management course and $120) and the charge was dismissed in December.
Summary
The narrator states that on October 8, 2023, an Orange City officer noticed a pickup truck towing a boat parked in a fire lane in front of a Publix grocery store. The officer requested documents from the 19-year-old driver and wrote citations for parking, window tint and no proof of insurance. During an argument, the driver spoke loudly to a passing customer, and the officer arrested him for disorderly conduct, taking him to the ground while attempting to handcuff him. The narrator concludes the arrest likely lacked probable cause, that the speech was likely protected, and that the officer's account to colleagues was contradicted by his body camera. The narrator also notes the driver was parked illegally and that the use of force would likely be considered minimal under Eleventh Circuit precedent. The charge was later dismissed after a deferred prosecution agreement.
CopFax assessment (opinion)
How police handled it
Not yet assessed
This is CopFax's opinion based on the source video and records linked on this page. The factual summary above is separate from this assessment.
Officers involved
No officers identified yet.
Related public records
No public records linked yet.