First Amendment auditor
James Madison Media
YouTube @jamesmadisonmedia (opens in a new tab)
First Amendment auditorYouTube
- Type
- First Amendment auditor
- Platform
- YouTube
- Incidents documented on CopFax
- 9
- Departments involved
- 8
- Officers named
- 1
- YouTube subscribers
- 409,000
Incidents (9)
- Ponce Inlet traffic stop for loud music leads to marijuana confiscation and citywide trespass warning
Ponce Inlet Police Department · Ponce Inlet, FL
An officer stopped a driver for music plainly audible from about 25 feet, which he described as a state law violation. The driver, who lives in Daytona, told the officer he had a small amount of marijuana and no medical card. The officer said he would confiscate it rather than arrest, checked the driver's pockets with his agreement, searched the vehicle because of the odor, and issued a written warning for the music. A corporal then directed that the driver be given a trespass warning covering town-owned property such as parks. A second officer questioned whether this was allowed since the man was not on town property, and the corporal said he would take responsibility. The narrator states that the police department later told him it should not have happened and that the man was told he could return to town.
- Palm Bay officers respond to battery report against police chief at City Hall
Palm Bay Police Department · Palm Bay, FL
A man who films public interactions (an auditor) told Palm Bay police that the police chief touched him without permission at City Hall and asked responding officers to take a battery report. An officer who responded said the officer was not present for the touching, asked for the man's name and ID, and was repeatedly asked whether an arrest would be made if the touch was proven on video. A second officer, a commander, was also mentioned. The second officer said it was a conflict of interest for him to handle an allegation against his chief, offered to contact the Brevard County Sheriff's Office for an independent investigation, and said he would write a report documenting everything on body camera. The auditor declined to pursue it, saying he believed the process would be a waste of time.
- Jacksonville officers respond to school complaint about sign holder on public sidewalk
Jacksonville Sheriff's Office · Duval County, FL
The video shows a man holding a sign reading "God bless homeless vets" on a sidewalk outside a private school in Jacksonville, Florida. A school-affiliated woman tells him to leave and says she will get the police. Police arrive, and an officer asks if he is soliciting money; he says yes and says he will stay. The officer relays that school security, described as a retired JSO chief, said the school's property line ends at a sign, and the man says that is the public crosswalk and public property. A female officer then makes remarks the narrator describes as insulting, including saying "probably why you're in that position," and the sign holder is told he can file a complaint (vehicle 2998).
- Sanford officers ask for ID during trespass warning outside Walmart (comparison clip)
Sanford Police Department · Sanford, FL
The narrator plays a short clip, which he describes as showing the Sanford Police Department outside a Walmart. In it, an officer asks for identification in connection with a trespass warning. A person at the scene, who appears to be recording, objects. This person says that requiring ID is a rights violation and an unlawful search. The officer replies that trespass after warning is the crime, and the person responds that issuing the warning itself is not a crime. The narrator uses the clip to support his argument that officers cannot compel ID during a trespass warning. The transcript does not make clear how the clip ended.
- Polk County deputies request ID from man in parked car after business trespass complaint
Polk County Sheriff's Office · Polk County, FL
A man recording from his parked car said a business employee told him she would call police, and he waited for deputies to arrive. Deputies asked for his identification so they could issue a trespass warning, and he repeatedly declined, saying he had not been on the property or broken any law. He said he would leave once the deputies left. A deputy then told him he was parked in the street and said he was stopping him, and the man called this retaliation. The deputy ordered him to step out of the car. The man asked whether he would be arrested if he did not hand over ID and said he would give it 'under threat of arrest.' The narrator states that the man was then handcuffed and removed from the vehicle, though that part is not shown in the transcript.
- St. Augustine officer tells sign holder that city hall area is not a public forum
St. Augustine Police Department · St. Augustine, FL
The narrator states that a man holding a sign reading 'God bless the homeless vets' in front of a St. Augustine building was told it was not a free speech area. In the video clip, an officer says he called the downtown unit and then a city attorney, and tells the man the area is not a public forum. The officer says the city drew up its charter to designate it that way and that the restriction includes the parking garage. When asked, the officer identifies himself as Corporal Korea (as heard). The narrator disputes the officer's position and says the man had demonstrated there before.
- Orange City officer shoots man holding knife outside bank after Taser use
Orange City Police Department · Orange City, FL
Body camera footage shows an Orange City officer following a man holding a knife on foot while repeatedly ordering him to drop it. The officer is heard warning the man not to approach people near a Jiffy Lube and not to open the door of a bank, and radio traffic reports Taser deployments. The officer later says in a recorded debrief that the man grabbed the door and he fired one shot. The narrator says the police chief stated officers tried to deescalate verbally and with a Taser that was not effective. The description states the man was hospitalized in stable condition and that the Florida Department of Law Enforcement was notified to investigate.
- Park supervisor calls 911 about man openly carrying rifle-style pistol at Edgewater park
Edgewater Police Department · Edgewater, FL
A park supervisor called 911 after seeing the video's host openly carrying an AR-15 style pistol on a skateboard or similar ride at Whistle Stop Park. On the recorded call, the supervisor said he did not know what the law was, that the firearm was not being handled or pointed at anyone, and that he was calling for safety reasons. The host said open carry is legal in Florida and that the park rules list no firearm prohibition, citing preemption. The host stayed in the park and said the supervisor's call was equivalent to asking him to leave, which the supervisor denied. After about 15 minutes an officer arrived, spoke briefly with the host, and agreed that open carry is legal in Florida.
- Edgewater police pursue e-bike rider through neighborhoods and onto US 1
Edgewater Police Department · Edgewater, FL
Radio traffic in the video describes a fleeing vehicle, a white male in a black shirt and black shorts on an e-bike, northbound on a street the captions render as "Fern Pal." The narrator states the pursuit went through residential streets and into oncoming traffic on U.S. 1, and says one car had to move out of the way of a motorcycle officer. He also says a motorcycle officer appeared to take out a Taser while driving. After the rider stopped, the audio includes an exchange between the rider and officers about whether he knew he was being chased, and the narrator identifies one speaker as the police chief. The narrator criticizes the department's pursuit practices, says the department posted a group photo with the rider on Facebook, and says he heard a helicopter was also requested.
Departments involved (8)
- Edgewater Police Department
Edgewater, FL
- Jacksonville Sheriff's Office
Duval County, FL
- Orange City Police Department
Orange City, FL
- Palm Bay Police Department
Palm Bay, FL
- Polk County Sheriff's Office
Polk County, FL
- Ponce Inlet Police Department
Ponce Inlet, FL
- Sanford Police Department
Sanford, FL
- St. Augustine Police Department
St. Augustine, FL
Officers named (1)
- Nicholas Agosto
Officer, Orange City Police Department
CopFax documents incidents from James Madison Media's publicly available videos, with 9 incidents reviewed and published so far. Each incident page embeds the original video and credits the creator.
Get listed: creators can ask CopFax to document their channel.
CopFax lists independent creators who cover police and civil-rights topics. Their views are their own, and listing a channel isn't an endorsement.