First Amendment auditor
First Amendment Protection Agency
YouTube @FirstAmendmentProtectionAgency (opens in a new tab)
First Amendment auditorYouTube
- Type
- First Amendment auditor
- Platform
- YouTube
- Incidents documented on CopFax
- 61
- Departments involved
- 49
- Officers named
- 7
- YouTube subscribers
- 246,000
Incidents (61)
- Officers arrest content creator on trespassing charge outside McDonald's
Woodhaven Police Department · Woodhaven, MI
The narrator states that two days earlier, another content creator was arrested in front of a McDonald's on a trespassing charge. In the clip, an officer tells the group that McDonald's does not want them on the property and that they will be arrested for trespassing if they go inside. The group says they will leave and stand on the sidewalk, and several people say the creator was never told to leave by the business and had not been trespassed. Additional officers arrive, and the creator is taken into custody while bystanders say the charge will not hold up. The narrator says the creator has a lawyer and that more details are in the creator's own video.
- Colorado Springs officers respond to dispensary complaint about person filming
Colorado Springs Police Department · Colorado Springs, CO
A man filming from a sidewalk near the High Tops dispensary says he is on a public right of way and not on the property. Dispensary employees asked him to leave, saying customers were uncomfortable and that he was following people. The employees called police. Officer Rodriguez arrived, gave a CAD number and business card, said the call concerned a disagreement over whether the man was leaving the property, and said a supervisor would clarify. A supervisor who gave his surname as Fudge and a number of 3171 then spoke with the man, asked about his purpose, and advised him to be careful around upset customers. No citation or arrest is shown, and the man stayed where he was as the officers left.
- Lower Merion officers respond to call about man filming outside dispensary
Lower Merion Township Police Department · Lower Merion Township, PA
A self-described First Amendment auditor filmed from a public sidewalk outside a medical marijuana dispensary. After several employees and a patron questioned him, two Lower Merion Township officers arrived, and the auditor says they were called. One officer said sidewalk recording is not a crime and asked what the filming was for. The officers said the auditor was not trespassing or causing a disturbance and asked him not to go inside and record. They gave him an incident number card with names and badge numbers and told him how to request body camera footage.
- Officer activates lights behind auditor and declines to provide a copy of recording
Auburn Police Department · Auburn, MA
Near the end of the video, the narrator says an officer activated emergency lights right behind him, which he says startled him. The auditor asked whether he would get a copy of something, and an officer answered no. The transcript does not show the reason for the contact or how it ended. The narrator later says cooler heads prevailed and the day wrapped up.
- Cranston officers tell auditor to stay off private lot at liquor store
Cranston Police Department · Cranston, RI
A First Amendment auditor was filming outside a liquor store in Cranston, Rhode Island when two officers arrived after someone reportedly called. One officer told the auditor to stay off the private parking lot and said he could stand where he was and film. When the auditor asked whether he was being trespassed, the officer said that if he went onto the lot he would be trespassed, but that at that moment the business had only asked that he stay off the property. The auditor said afterward that he felt the officers gave unnecessary directives, and he left without being trespassed.
- Checotah officers respond to report about man filming outside dispensary
Checotah Police Department · Checotah, OK
A first amendment auditor was filming from near two side-by-side businesses in Checotah, Oklahoma, when a dispensary worker told him a customer had called police. An officer who gave her name as Mitchell arrived, said the caller reported he had been recording, yelling at customers, and had asked that he be removed from the property. The auditor declined to answer questions and told her the worker had said otherwise. She went to speak with the business, and several more officers arrived. A sergeant then told the auditor he could stay and record, as long as he stayed off the business property. The auditor says the officer first told him he would be removed and then denied it.
- Worcester officer takes report from auditor after pepper spray incident
Worcester Police Department · Worcester, MA
The narrator, a First Amendment auditor, says a man confronted him outside a dispensary, threatened to smash his camera, and was pepper-sprayed by the auditor, who describes it as self-defense. The auditor called police and waited for them. An officer arrived, asked what happened and what the auditor needed, and took a description of the other man, who had left before police arrived. The officer said filming from a public sidewalk is allowed and that it is wise to call police after a self-defense incident. He explained that a private property owner can ask someone to leave. He also gave the auditor an incident number and his badge number, and asked him not to harass anyone.
- Broken Arrow officers contact auditor filming outside cannabis dispensary
Broken Arrow Police Department · Broken Arrow, OK
A First Amendment auditor was filming from a public area outside a dispensary in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma. A dispensary worker asked him why he was recording and said she would call police. Two officers arrived, and one asked the auditor to step onto the sidewalk, saying the curb area belonged to the business. The auditor said he was within his rights, and the officer then asked for ID, which the auditor declined to give. The officer later acknowledged the auditor had a right to be there, provided a call for service number, and ended the contact cordially.
- Police respond to dispensary manager's complaint about sidewalk filming
Clifton Heights Police Department · Clifton Heights, PA
A video creator filmed from a public sidewalk outside the Zen Leaf dispensary. A manager told him he could not film the building, citing HIPAA, and later said he would call the police. The creator disputed the HIPAA claim and said he was on a public sidewalk. Per the creator, police cruisers arrived and parked in front of the entrance. The transcript has no clear audio of any officer's words or actions. At the end the creator says officers avoided him, joked and left without giving a CAD number.
- Millcreek officers speak with auditor filming Dunkin' drive-thru after complaint
Millcreek Township Police Department, Erie County · Erie County, PA
A first amendment auditor was filming from a public area near a Dunkin' drive-thru in Erie, PA. Two Millcreek police officers arrived and told him that employees were complaining and that he was making people uncomfortable by filming customers. The auditor asked for names and badge numbers; one officer said "173" and the other pointed to her name tag. The officers said the business wanted him to move along and then left, with no arrest or citation shown. The auditor stated afterward that the officers had an attitude and that one called him a derogatory term as he walked away.
- Off-duty officer questions auditor about filming outside St. Augustine dispensary
St. Augustine Police Department · St. Augustine, FL
A man who said he is a cop approached the auditor outside a dispensary and asked why he was filming. He said he did not want to appear on the 11:00 news and claimed he would have to sign a release to be shown. The auditor replied that filming in public does not require a release and cited the public view doctrine. The man said 'Trust me, man. I'm a cop,' and the auditor questioned whether he was really a cop. The exchange ended without any stated enforcement action.
- Emmet Township officers advise auditor not to enter dispensary property
Emmett Township Police Department · Emmett Township, MI
A video creator filming from a spot he described as public area near a Battle Creek dispensary was approached by a dispensary worker who questioned the filming. Police later arrived, and a sergeant told the creator that the business did not want him on its property. The creator questioned why the message came through police rather than the business, and the officers said they were not accusing him of wrongdoing and that he would have to leave if staff asked him to. Later, an officer told him he was not wanted on the property for that day only, and the creator remained in the public area and the officers left.
- Millcreek officer addresses blocking of sidewalk after employee 911 call about auditor
Millcreek Township Police Department, Erie County · Erie County, PA
After a Dunkin' employee said he had called 911 over the auditor's filming, officers returned to the scene with emergency lights on. The employee and the auditor argued, and the employee told the auditor that people were scared. Officers spoke with the parties and one told the auditor to keep moving on the sidewalk so as not to block a passageway. The auditor asked whether faking a charge at people would be an arrestable offense; an officer said no, and that disorderly conduct can apply depending on the situation and the officer's discretion. No arrest is shown and the video description says the matter was dismissed.
- Tupelo officer arrests First Amendment auditor for loitering outside dispensary after 911 call
Tupelo Police Department · Tupelo, MS
A dispensary employee called 911 saying a man was filming outside and she wanted him gone. An officer arrived, asked the auditor to come over to talk, and attempted to pat him down. The auditor repeatedly invoked the Fifth Amendment and said he was on public property. The officer told him he was being arrested for criminal loitering, and later said disorderly conduct was also a charge. The narrator states the charges were later dismissed. The officer said he did not need a reason to be on public property to be told he was loitering if he could not give one, and cited a state bill on loitering.
- Sheriff's deputy tells recorder he is trespassed near Flock facility in Smyrna
Cobb County Sheriff's Office · Cobb County, GA
During a livestream from a public road near the Flock manufacturing facility, a uniformed officer approached the recorder and asked if he was a YouTuber. The officer said the facility did not want him on the property and that the property line was marked nearby, and said he was already trespassed from the facility's property. The recorder said he had not entered the property and asked for the officer's name and badge number, which the officer declined to give. The exchange ended cordially, and the recorder later said he believed the officer was from the Cobb County Sheriff's Office, based on his own observation of a vehicle.
- Worcester officer responds to calls about man filming at Starbucks drive-thru and issues trespass notice
Worcester Police Department · Worcester, MA
A man filming people at a Starbucks drive-thru on Grafton Street in Worcester, Massachusetts was approached by a uniformed officer who said someone had called about him recording people in the drive-thru. The officer asked for the filmer's reason for recording, and the filmer asked why the officer had parked across two spaces. The officer said he was responding to a call and that multiple people had called. The officer then said the business wanted the filmer off the property and that he was trespassed indefinitely, but could remain on the sidewalk side. The encounter ended with the officer telling the group they were dismissed.
- Houston officers respond to Starbucks call about people filming from sidewalk
Houston Police Department · Houston, TX
Two people filming a Starbucks from a public sidewalk were approached by an employee and a private security guard, who said filming the building was against company policy. After the security guard appeared to make a phone call, patrol cars arrived. An officer identified as Torres and his partner spoke with the group. According to the video, the officers said the group could record anything in public view from the sidewalk and should stay out of the building, and they did not ask for ID. The auditors thanked the officers for being professional, and the officers left after a short, cordial exchange.
- Police approach auditor at boat ramp dock in Pasadena, Texas, per narrator
Pasadena Police Department · Pasadena, TX
The narrator says the auditor's livestream began with police coming up to the dock while dealing with another person who was using the dock. He states the officers acted kindly and cordially toward the auditor. Later in the footage, the auditor appears to say that officers had been called and that a different group of officers was on scene, but the officers' actions are not clearly audible in the transcript. The remainder of the video covers a separate stabbing of the auditor by a masked person, which is not a police encounter. The narrator also says police were checking business and Flock cameras afterward, but no officer interaction is shown.
- Police arrive at Cincinnati dispensary during recording audit; no interaction shown
Cincinnati Police Department · Cincinnati, OH
Two men recorded from a public sidewalk outside the Ascend cannabis dispensary in Cincinnati, Ohio, and most of the video shows exchanges with customers and a worker. During one of those exchanges a woman says the police are there. At the end, the narrator states that workers called the police on people standing on the sidewalk with phones. He also says the officer who had previously arrested the other auditor arrived, recognized him right away, and did not want further problems. The transcript has no audible officer interaction, no officer names, and no stated outcome.
- St. Louis officers tell filmers to stay off Starbucks property after customer complaints
St. Louis Police Department · St. Louis, MO
Two first amendment auditors filmed outside a Starbucks in St. Louis, Missouri, and employees and a customer questioned them and said they would call police. Several police officers arrived, with the narrator counting six. An officer told the auditors they could remain on the sidewalk but were not welcome on the property or inside, and said not to block the drive-thru. The auditors asked officers for names and badge numbers, and the officers appeared to give some. The auditors left after about 21 minutes of video.
- Crestview officer speaks with auditor filming at dispensary and finds no violation
Crestview Police Department · Crestview, FL
A first amendment auditor films people entering and leaving a dispensary in Florida. After a 911 call that the auditor says a patron made, an officer arrives, asks for the auditor's name and badge number exchange, and tells him he is not doing anything wrong. The officer says only that the auditor cannot block a public sidewalk, and the auditor replies that both of them are just standing there. The officer then speaks with a patron, advises her to ignore the auditor and go home, and gives the auditor a CAD number for the 911 call before leaving. The narrator calls the officers professional.
- Auburn police respond to call about auditor filming outside liquor store
Auburn Police Department · Auburn, MA
The narrator, who says he is filming at the Colony Liquor and Wine Shop in Auburn, Massachusetts, states that Auburn police arrived after a caller complained. An officer approached, greeted the auditor as someone he had met before, and said someone had called and that the officers told the caller the auditor was recording. The officer said there was nothing they could do and that he just had to come. The auditor asked for and received a CAD or call number, and the contact ended quickly and cordially.
- Bellingham officer asks auditor for ID while he films bank ATM area
Bellingham Police Department · Bellingham, MA
A man filming outside a Middlesex Savings Bank in Bellingham, Massachusetts was approached by an officer on a bicycle. The officer said several people had called with concerns and that he wanted to check on what the man was doing. He also said he was worried about the man's safety near the edge of the road. The officer asked repeatedly for ID so he could document who he spoke with, and the man declined. The officer said there was no law against asking, then told him he was dismissed and left. The man stayed where he was and said afterward that the request had no valid reason.
- Mansfield officer declines to give name and badge number to auditor outside cannabis dispensary
Mansfield Police Department · Mansfield, OH
A First Amendment auditor was filming from public property outside a cannabis dispensary in Mansfield, Ohio. A dispensary worker came out, asked what he was doing, and was told it was public filming; the worker said he had no problem with it. Several police vehicles later arrived, and the auditor says an officer spoke with the worker inside. The auditor asked one officer for his name and badge number. The officer said there was no reason to engage, that the auditor was not doing anything, and that he could call in to ask. The officer then used profanity toward the auditor, who responded calmly and left. The narrator says the officer had a predisposition toward him.
- Lorain County deputy responds to dispensary call about man filming, issues trespass warning
Lorain County Sheriff's Office · Lorain County, OH
A first amendment auditor filmed outside a cannabis dispensary in Lorain, Ohio. A dispensary employee approached him, said he was on private property, and said the sheriff would be called. The auditor says a deputy arrived with lights activated. The deputy asked whether the auditor had been inside causing a disturbance, and the auditor declined to answer further and said he was dismissed. A second deputy later told the auditor he was trespassed from the property and would be arrested if he went inside. The deputy also said he could be cited for causing a disturbance if he blocked the road again.
- Grafton officers respond to plaza owner's complaint about person filming and pepper spray
Grafton Police Department · Grafton, MA
A plaza owner called 911 and told the dispatcher that a person recording outside his businesses had pointed pepper spray in his face. Two officers arrived, spoke with the owner and then the person filming, who said he had been bumped and had drawn pepper spray in self-defense. The officers told the plaza owner that recording people in public is lawful and that the filmer was no longer on his property. They said that, as they understood Massachusetts law, they lacked power of arrest for the alleged assault and battery. They offered to help either side pursue charges or a no-trespass order, and the filmer said he would file charges himself. The filmer declined to show ID and rated the officers 10 out of 10.
- Berea officers question auditor outside dispensary after call about disturbance
Berea Police Department · Berea, OH
A first amendment auditor filming outside a dispensary in Berea, Ohio was approached by officers who said they had received a call. An officer asked whether the auditor was intoxicated, whether he had ID, and for his name, saying he was called for a law enforcement purpose after a report of someone disturbing the property. The auditor declined to identify himself, asked what crime was alleged, and moved about 20 feet away. Later an officer said the caller reported the auditor was yelling at customers in the parking lot, and advised him not to bother patrons or cause a disturbance. An officer also asked the auditor to follow his finger, which the auditor declined, and the officers left without any arrest being shown.
- Springfield officers respond to dispensary complaint about person filming on sidewalk
Springfield Police Department · Springfield, MA
A security guard at a dispensary on Boston Road called the Springfield police non-emergency line to report a man recording near the business, saying customers were agitated. The dispatcher asked about weapons and told the caller not to approach him. Two officers arrived, spoke with the caller, and said the man was on the sidewalk, was recording legally, and they could do nothing. They then spoke with the person filming, gave their names and badge numbers, and provided the call for service number when asked. The person filming thanked them for being professional and cordial.
- Colonie police respond to TD Bank call about man filming near ATM
Colonie Town Police Department · Colonie Town, NY
A First Amendment auditor filmed from a public roadway near a TD Bank in Albany, NY, and a woman at the ATM objected and said she would call police. Two officers arrived and told the auditor that bank staff did not want him filming on bank property, but said he was not being trespassed. The officers said filming people at an ATM involves confidential information, which the auditor disputed. The auditor asked about body cameras, and the officers said the cameras had not been turned on while they spoke with bank staff but were on during the roadside conversation. The officers then ended the contact and the auditor was told he was dismissed.
- Plymouth Township officers speak with auditor outside Plymouth Meeting dispensary
Plymouth Township Police Department, Montgomery County · Montgomery County, PA
The auditor filmed outside a dispensary in Plymouth Meeting, Pennsylvania, and an officer arrived after a call. The officer told the auditor that he was on public property and could film. The officer gave his name and badge number when asked and said he would try to get a report number after speaking with the caller. A second officer also gave a surname and badge number at the end, and the auditor thanked both for being professional.
- Chicopee police check on auditor filming outside dispensary and confirm sidewalk filming is permitted
Chicopee Police Department · Chicopee, MA
A First Amendment auditor filmed from a public sidewalk outside the Theory Wellness dispensary. A man who appeared to be dispensary staff asked him to move and said he was not allowed to film people entering and leaving, and the auditor said he was on the public sidewalk. Police later arrived, an officer asked why he was filming, and a second officer introduced himself, said the auditor was on the sidewalk, and said he was good to go. The officer provided a CAD number at the auditor's request and said the business had not formally trespassed him but could if he went onto the property.
- Brimfield officer takes public records request at police station door
Brimfield Police Department · Brimfield, MA
During a livestream, an auditor stood outside the Brimfield Police and Fire building on a Friday afternoon. He said he had called several times and that the building was locked before the stated 5 p.m. closing. After a viewer in the chat said an officer was on the way, an officer came to the door and spoke with him. The officer said he was new, had no access to the records and had no sergeant on duty. He offered to pass along a written request and phone number to the sergeant. The auditor thanked him for his honesty.
- Edison, NJ officer reportedly declines to remove speaker from board of education meeting
Edison Township Police Department · Edison Township, NJ
The guest briefly mentions his most viewed video, in which he says an Edison, New Jersey officer refused to remove a man speaking at a public board of education meeting. He states that a board member, possibly the president, wanted the man removed after disliking what he said. The guest names the officer as Officer Stout and presents this as an example of good police conduct. No footage or further detail is shown in this video.
- Foster police officer tells auditor not to enter dispensary property and later patrols nearby
Foster Police Department · Foster, RI
A First Amendment auditor filmed the parking lot of a dispensary from what he described as public property. A police officer pulled in, said the dispensary had called him, and told the auditor not to come on the property or go in the street. The officer said the auditor was not doing anything wrong at that point. The auditor asked if he was being trespassed from the property, and the officer said yes. Later the officer followed him in a patrol vehicle, and said he was doing patrol on Route 6. The auditor alleges retaliation, and the officer is not heard confirming that.
- East Greenbush officers respond to call about man filming outside dispensary
East Greenbush Town Police Department · East Greenbush Town, NY
The narrator, who films in public, says he was recording near the Smoky Paradise Dispensary in East Greenbush, New York, when a woman asked why he was filming and said she would call police. Officers then arrived and said they had received a call about him recording people and wanted to "ease their mind." One officer told him he was completely fine to record and asked what the recording was for, and the narrator declined to say. The narrator asked for names, badge numbers and an incident number, and the officers gave them. The officers said they would tell the caller that filming was his First Amendment right. The narrator later said the first officer's questions were unnecessary but that a second officer, possibly a supervisor, ended the contact better.
- Dispatcher tells auditor a dispensary requested the police presence
Foster Police Department · Foster, RI
The narrator calls the police to ask whether the officer waiting in the parking lot is a real officer. The narrator says the officer told him he was waiting for him to do something wrong. The dispatcher says the dispensary called to report someone harassing and videotaping people, and that this is why the officer is there. The dispatcher also says the narrator is not doing anything wrong and the officer will not do anything. The dispatcher confirms the man is a real officer.
- Monroe Township officers respond to call about man filming outside dispensary
Monroe Township Police Department, Gloucester County · Gloucester County, NJ
A man filming from a street corner near a dispensary in Williamstown, NJ, was approached by a uniformed officer who said a call had come in about him filming people. The officer said the encounter was audio and video recorded, asked if the man needed assistance, and left after the man said no. At the man's request, the officer gave a case number, his name and badge number as heard. The officer told the man that filming was legal and that callers can remain anonymous. The man asked whether the caller would be told not to call police over recording, and the officer said people are allowed to contact police if something seems out of the ordinary.
- Police reportedly escort auditor away from cannabis dispensary after employee and owner complaints
Colonie Town Police Department · Colonie Town, NY
The narrator, a self-described First Amendment auditor, films in public outside a cannabis dispensary and speaks with several people who ask why he is recording. One person says police have been called (about 7:44), and a later speaker relays that employees are uncomfortable with him filming. The police response is not shown in this part. At the end, the narrator says the owner followed him and tried to start a fight until police arrived, and he thanks the 'Colony Police' for escorting him down the road. He says the full interaction will be in a part two.
- Manatee County deputy speaks with auditor outside Bradenton dispensary
Manatee County Sheriff's Office · Manatee County, FL
A first amendment auditor was filming from a public sidewalk outside a cannabis dispensary in Bradenton, Florida. Partway through, the auditor remarks that a Manatee County Sheriff's unit has arrived, and a deputy later approaches. The deputy said the auditor was on a public sidewalk, could record, and asked that things not escalate into harassment either way. When asked for a name, badge number and CAD number, the deputy gave a name and badge number but said the auditor could call records for the incident number and declined to look it up. The auditor said afterward that the deputy started professionally but was unhelpful on the CAD number.
- Mashpee police respond to call about filming near dispensary, tell auditor recording is allowed
Mashpee Police Department · Mashpee, MA
A first amendment auditor was filming from a public right of way outside a dispensary in Mashpee, Massachusetts. An officer arrived and said the call was originally about the auditor standing in the roadway. The auditor reported that a worker had swerved a car toward him and gave a plate number, which the officer said he would take down. The officer told the auditor several times that he is allowed to record on public property, and told the dispensary employee that the auditor could not film inside the establishment if told not to. The officer asked the auditor to stay off the roadway, gave a call number, and explained how to file a public records request.
- Journalists reportedly denied entry to police-organized event on NYC City Hall steps
New York City Police Department · New York City, NY
A guest, described by the host as an independent journalist, says he and two other creators were not allowed into a public event on the City Hall steps in New York City, which was organized by police unions to discuss people they called social media agitators. He states officers told them they lacked proper press credentials, and that the NYPD issues such credentials. He claims a taller man in a suit pushed him back without identifying himself, and that a detective elbowed him and then denied it. He says his 360 degree camera recorded the contact. This account is the guest's description in a livestream discussion; the footage itself is not shown in this video.
- Sheriff's officer speaks with auditor outside Jacksonville dispensary after 911 call about recording
Jacksonville Sheriff's Office · Duval County, FL
The auditor was recording traffic from public property near a cannabis dispensary in Jacksonville, Florida. An employee was heard on a 911 call asking police to arrest him for recording on the sidewalk, citing HIPAA. Earlier, an employee told the auditor it was illegal to film because of patient privacy, and the auditor asked her what the acronym stood for. A sheriff's officer then arrived, spoke with the dispensary employee, and then spoke with the auditor, calling the matter civil and acknowledging the auditor's right to record. The auditor thanked the officer for being professional, and the officer asked him to avoid aggressive situations.
- Philadelphia officer checks on man filming outside dispensary
Philadelphia Police Department · Philadelphia, PA
A first amendment auditor was filming from a public location near a dispensary in Philadelphia after an employee questioned him and appeared to make a phone call. A Philadelphia Police officer approached, asked what he was doing, and the auditor said he was making a video. The officer said he was just checking, that he was not kicking the auditor out, and that the auditor was fine to be on a public sidewalk. The officer stated his name and a badge number of 2539, and the auditor then asked for and received a CAD number.
- Philadelphia officers return after altercation and speak with auditor
Philadelphia Police Department · Philadelphia, PA
After a verbal dispute in which the auditor says he used pepper spray on a man who approached him, two Philadelphia Police officers arrived at the dispensary. The auditor said the other man had already left, and he suggested the officers had picked sides, though he showed no basis for that on camera. An officer asked if he needed police, and the auditor asked for a CAD number for this call, which differed from the first. The auditor thanked the officer, whom he called Mr. Gonzalez, and later described both officers as cordial and professional.
- Officer asks auditor about his recording and channel before leaving the dispensary lot
Foster Police Department · Foster, RI
Later in the video, an officer asks the narrator where he posts his recordings and whether he calls it work. The narrator says he does not discuss it while he is doing it. The officer says the narrator is trying to get a reaction but will not have a real conversation, and the narrator disagrees. The narrator then says the officer left, and he describes the officer's presence as retaliation.
- Foster RI officer tells auditor not to enter property or street while recording near dispensary
Foster Police Department · Foster, RI
The narrator, a video auditor, records from a sidewalk near a dispensary on Route 6 in Foster, Rhode Island. An officer asks why he is recording, and the narrator says he is not doing anything wrong. The officer says he is on patrol and will remain until the auditor does something wrong. He also tells the auditor not to come onto the property or go in the street and says he will arrest him if he has to. The narrator characterizes this as retaliation, while the officer describes it as patrol.
- Milford, Ohio officers speak with man filming outside US Bank after customer call
Miami Township Police Department, Clermont County · Clermont County, OH
A first amendment auditor was filming outside a US Bank in Milford, Ohio. An officer approached and said people had called about him filming. The officer asked for the auditor's name and the auditor asked for the officer's name and badge number, and the officer gave badge number 32 as heard. The auditor said he was just recording, and the officer left to get a CAD number. A second officer later gave his first name as John, wrote down his badge number and the CAD number, and said it was a customer, not the bank, who called.
- South Bound Brook officers respond to call about man recording outside dispensary
South Bound Brook Police Department · South Bound Brook, NJ
Officers arrived with lights and sirens after a 911 call about a man filming outside a dispensary. The officers spoke with dispensary staff, who said they had not called, and then with the man recording. An officer told him that recording is not against the law and that he had committed no crime, and said the only restriction was not blocking a walkway. The officers gave their names and badge information on request. They said they did not know who called and that the call was described to them differently than what they found. They then phoned in and read out a CAD number when asked, and told him he could keep recording.
- Colorado Springs officer takes statement from auditor after physical altercation outside dispensary
Colorado Springs Police Department · Colorado Springs, CO
An auditor filming outside a Star Buds dispensary in Colorado Springs says a man approached him, told him to put the camera down, and a physical fight followed. The auditor says he pepper sprayed the man and that the man grabbed him and they fought. After the fight, a responding officer asks the auditor what happened, whether he has ID, and for his name. The auditor says in the description that the other man is being charged with damage to property and assault, and that he believes a woman who struck him was not charged. The transcript does not show the officer's name or any arrest on camera.
- Framingham officer tells auditor he may remain on public sidewalk outside dispensary
Framingham Police Department · Framingham, MA
A First Amendment auditor filmed outside the Tomesco Wellness Center in Framingham, Massachusetts. A store employee wearing a security lanyard told him not to film, and a manager said he was on private property and asked him to leave. The manager said she would call police, and the auditor said police could only ask him to leave. A police officer arrived and told the auditor that as long as he stayed on the property line, he was allowed to be there. The officer said he would tell the staff that the auditor was fine.
- Portage officer declines to give call number to person recording at dispensary
Portage Police Department · Portage, MI
A first amendment auditor was recording outside the Sky Mint Cannabis Dispensary in Portage, Michigan. An officer parked, appeared to start his body camera, and entered the dispensary. When the auditor asked for the CAD or incident number for the call, the officer replied that the auditor did not know what he had been dispatched to and that he had not said a word to the auditor. The auditor said the officer had a bad attitude. The exchange was brief and no detention or enforcement action is described.
- Brimfield sergeant asks auditor for ID during consensual contact outside dispensary
Brimfield Police Department · Brimfield, MA
A sergeant responded to a reported complaint about a man filming outside a cannabis dispensary in Brimfield, Massachusetts. The sergeant asked for the auditor's ID and the reason for his presence, saying people had called to complain. The auditor asked for a CAD number, which the sergeant said had not been assigned yet, and asked whether he was being detained. The sergeant said the conversation was consensual, the auditor ended it, and the sergeant said state police were on the way. Later the sergeant gave a CAD number (as heard, 25-64 612) and said it appeared generated at 12:54.
- New Jersey State Police troopers respond to call about man filming dispensary from sidewalk
State Police · State, NJ
The auditor filmed a cannabis dispensary from a public sidewalk and road edge. A dispensary employee approached, said filming was concerning for customer privacy, and mentioned HIPAA, which the auditor disputed. Two state troopers later arrived after what one trooper described as a call about someone suspicious with a camera. The troopers told the auditor he was not required to answer questions, said the business did not want him on the property (a verbal trespass notice), then clarified he could be on the public side. They gave their badge numbers and explained how to request records through the division. The auditor said at the end that the troopers handled the encounter well.
- Champaign police officer questions auditors outside dispensary after business call
Champaign Police Department · Champaign, IL
After filming outside a dispensary, auditors went to a nearby coffee shop and noticed police approaching. An officer said the department had a call for service and that the dispensary reported people putting cameras in patrons' faces. The auditors declined to answer questions and said they had been on public property the whole time. The officer said that as long as they stayed on public property they were fine, then said that filming patrons could be disorderly conduct under state law. The auditors disputed this, asked for a supervisor, then the encounter ended with the auditors leaving.
- Tredyffrin officers respond to dispensary call about man filming from sidewalk
Tredyffrin Township Police Department · Tredyffrin Township, PA
A man filming from a public sidewalk outside a medical cannabis dispensary was questioned by employees, who said they were concerned about patients and license plates being recorded. An employee was seen on the phone with police, and two officers later arrived. The officers said the man was free to film from the sidewalk and that the dispensary wanted them to relay that staff felt uncomfortable. When asked, they declined to turn off their body cameras, and the man asked for names and badge numbers and a CAD number. The man described the officers as professional.
- Auditor files false report complaint at Grafton police headquarters
Grafton Police Department · Grafton, MA
The narrator, a First Amendment auditor, goes to the Grafton Police Department to file a complaint against a plaza owner. He states the owner told police on September 10th that the auditor had been on his property and had pulled a weapon, and that officers who responded accepted the narrator's video showing he stayed on the public easement. At headquarters, an officer identified as Palmer says he will convert the report to an arrest report, charge the owner criminally, and issue a summons, with the ADA likely to contact the auditor as a witness. The officer asks for ID, a phone number, and the video evidence. The auditor describes the officers as cordial and professional throughout.
- Englishtown detective speaks with auditor filming outside dispensary
Englishtown Police Department · Englishtown, NJ
A first amendment auditor was filming from a public sidewalk outside a dispensary in Englishtown, New Jersey, after a dispensary employee said police were being called. A detective who introduced himself as being with the Englishtown Police Department asked the auditor to take his hands out of his pockets, saying it was for safety. The auditor questioned this and declined to give his first name, asking whether the conversation was consensual. The detective asked if the auditor wanted to speak about what was going on. When the auditor said no, the detective told him he was dismissed and the encounter ended.
- Police arrive at Grand Rapids dispensary during public filming, no interaction with auditor
Grand Rapids Police Department · Grand Rapids, MI
A First Amendment auditor films from a public sidewalk outside a cannabis dispensary in Grand Rapids, Michigan. Several employees and customers ask why he is filming, and one customer tells him he has no right to record her. Around 20:15 the auditor remarks that police being in the parking lot makes people act erratic, and later suggests that staff were inside talking with police. At the end the narrator states that Grand Rapids police pulled up and that there was no conversation with them. The transcript does not show what the officers did, why they came, or whether they spoke with anyone, and the auditor's claim that staff called police is his own assumption.
- Newark officer explains easement and recording rights to dispensary staff and auditor
Newark Police Department · Newark, OH
A person filming from a public easement outside the Sunnyside Dispensary in Newark, Ohio, says dispensary staff approached him and said they would call police. A Newark Police Department officer arrived without emergency lights, spoke with the auditor, and said he had explained to the staff that the auditor was on an easement and was allowed to film what he could see. The officer said the business only asked that the auditor not come onto the property, and the auditor said he could be given a verbal trespass if needed. The officer gave his name, badge number and a CAD or report number on request, said his body camera was recording, and the auditor described the exchange as respectful and professional.
- Kalamazoo County deputies speak with auditor filming at Starbucks drive-thru
Kalamazoo County Sheriff's Office · Kalamazoo County, MI
Two Kalamazoo County Sheriff's deputies approached an auditor who was recording from a sidewalk near a Starbucks. The deputies said people at the Starbucks had called, reporting that he was filming cars in the drive-thru. They told him that if he stepped onto the property he would be trespassed, and the auditor asked whether they were speaking on behalf of the business. The auditor said no one had told him he could not be there, and the deputies asked for his name and offered to take it in exchange for theirs. The encounter ended without any stated arrest or citation.
- Cincinnati officers detain and arrest man recording outside bank
Cincinnati Police Department · Cincinnati, OH
The narrator states that a fellow auditor was arrested the previous day while recording from a sidewalk at the First Commonwealth Bank at 25 Garfield Place in Cincinnati, Ohio. In the footage, an officer asks the recorder what he is doing and says he is responding to a call. The recorder says he is recording and on the sidewalk, and declines to answer further questions. An officer says the man was recording a bank and asking about its layout, and asks whether he has any guns. The man is then handcuffed and placed in a police car. The narrator says the arrest was based on a 911 call and that the recorder was doing lawful activity. The transcript does not state any charges.
Departments involved (49)
- Auburn Police Department
Auburn, MA
- Bellingham Police Department
Bellingham, MA
- Berea Police Department
Berea, OH
- Brimfield Police Department
Brimfield, MA
- Broken Arrow Police Department
Broken Arrow, OK
- Champaign Police Department
Champaign, IL
- Checotah Police Department
Checotah, OK
- Chicopee Police Department
Chicopee, MA
- Cincinnati Police Department
Cincinnati, OH
- Clifton Heights Police Department
Clifton Heights, PA
- Cobb County Sheriff's Office
Cobb County, GA
- Colonie Town Police Department
Colonie Town, NY
- Colorado Springs Police Department
Colorado Springs, CO
- Cranston Police Department
Cranston, RI
- Crestview Police Department
Crestview, FL
- East Greenbush Town Police Department
East Greenbush Town, NY
- Edison Township Police Department
Edison Township, NJ
- Emmett Township Police Department
Emmett Township, MI
- Englishtown Police Department
Englishtown, NJ
- Foster Police Department
Foster, RI
- Framingham Police Department
Framingham, MA
- Grafton Police Department
Grafton, MA
- Grand Rapids Police Department
Grand Rapids, MI
- Houston Police Department
Houston, TX
- Jacksonville Sheriff's Office
Duval County, FL
- Kalamazoo County Sheriff's Office
Kalamazoo County, MI
- Lorain County Sheriff's Office
Lorain County, OH
- Lower Merion Township Police Department
Lower Merion Township, PA
- Manatee County Sheriff's Office
Manatee County, FL
- Mansfield Police Department
Mansfield, OH
- Mashpee Police Department
Mashpee, MA
- Miami Township Police Department, Clermont County
Clermont County, OH
- Millcreek Township Police Department, Erie County
Erie County, PA
- Monroe Township Police Department, Gloucester County
Gloucester County, NJ
- New York City Police Department
New York City, NY
- Newark Police Department
Newark, OH
- Pasadena Police Department
Pasadena, TX
- Philadelphia Police Department
Philadelphia, PA
- Plymouth Township Police Department, Montgomery County
Montgomery County, PA
- Portage Police Department
Portage, MI
- South Bound Brook Police Department
South Bound Brook, NJ
- Springfield Police Department
Springfield, MA
- St. Augustine Police Department
St. Augustine, FL
- St. Louis Police Department
St. Louis, MO
- State Police
State, NJ
- Tredyffrin Township Police Department
Tredyffrin Township, PA
- Tupelo Police Department
Tupelo, MS
- Woodhaven Police Department
Woodhaven, MI
- Worcester Police Department
Worcester, MA
Officers named (7)
- David Muse
Badge 85
- Officer Aaron Petricca
Badge 154
- Officer Janice
Badge 420
- Officer Jordan Sawyer
Badge 249
- Officer Jose Diaz
Badge 306
- Sergeant Lucas Kraus
Badge 8
- Sergeant Wayne Mark
Badge 703
CopFax documents incidents from First Amendment Protection Agency's publicly available videos, with 61 incidents reviewed and published so far. Each incident page embeds the original video and credits the creator.
Get listed: creators can ask CopFax to document their channel.
CopFax lists independent creators who cover police and civil-rights topics. Their views are their own, and listing a channel isn't an endorsement.