First Amendment auditor
Bay Area Transparency
YouTube @bayareatransparency1722 (opens in a new tab)
First Amendment auditorYouTube
- Type
- First Amendment auditor
- Platform
- YouTube
- Incidents documented on CopFax
- 9
- Departments involved
- 5
- Officers named
- 0
- YouTube subscribers
- 365,000
Incidents (9)
- Post office employees and San Mateo County deputies confront auditor over filming in San Carlos lobby
San Mateo County Sheriff's Office · San Mateo County, CA
A first amendment auditor filmed inside the San Carlos post office lobby. Employees told him photography was not allowed in a federal building, and a supervisor demanded he leave and said she would call police. Responding officers, described by the auditor as sheriff's personnel, asked him to leave, asked for his ID and press credentials, and told him he was trespassing. The auditor cited a posted federal regulation (poster 7) allowing filming in lobbies for news purposes, declined to give ID, and accused an officer of standing inches from his face. A plainclothes officer gave a name and badge number, and a later-arriving officer told the auditor the lobby was public, that he had a right to be there, and that local police had been advised. The auditor was not arrested in the footage.
- Yreka officers respond to VA clinic call about person recording in lobby (first visit)
Yreka Police Department · Yreka, CA
The video creator, a first amendment auditor, was recording in the lobby of a VA clinic in Yreka, California. Staff told him he could not film, and he cited a posted VA regulation allowing news photography in entrances, lobbies and foyers. A staff member requested police assistance, and officers arrived and spoke with him. According to the auditor, the officers read the posted regulation, were cordial, and took no enforcement action. A detective who gave a spelling of his name was also friendly toward the auditor.
- SFPD officers ask auditor to leave Human Services office over filming
San Francisco Police Department · San Francisco, CA
A video creator filmed inside a San Francisco Human Services office. Staff and security told him that photography was not allowed and asked him to stop, and a staff member put a hand toward his camera. A staff member said police had been called, and later officers arrived near closing time. The officers said staff asked for his removal, and they said he would be arrested for trespass if he did not leave. He said he was leaving under threat of arrest and left.
- Officers speak with auditor at VA clinic after staff report during return visit
Yreka Police Department · Yreka, CA
On a return visit the following Monday, the auditor was again recording at the VA clinic while seeking to file a records request in person. Staff had called police, and officers arrived. One officer told the auditor he had consulted a VA police contact who said the site was privately owned and that obstructing business could be a misdemeanor. The auditor cited California Penal Code 602.1(d) and the posted federal regulation. The officer said fair enough, acknowledged his points, and said his chief was still looking into whether the auditor could be removed. The officer said he would err on the side of caution to avoid violating anyone's rights. A clinic employee asked that he be removed, and the auditor left voluntarily.
- Yreka lieutenant follows First Amendment auditor at county education office
Yreka Police Department · Yreka, CA
A man filming in public areas of the Siskiyou County Office of Education in Yreka, CA, is approached by a police lieutenant who walks alongside him. The lieutenant says he does not have to explain his actions, then says employees feel unsafe and he is there to make sure everyone is safe. The auditor repeatedly asks whether the lieutenant has reasonable suspicion of a crime, and the lieutenant says he is not treating him as a criminal. The lieutenant also mentions a pat-down and a K9 in the exchange, and the auditor declines. The auditor says he was never ordered to leave.
- Eugene police arrest auditor for trespass after earlier trespass encounter
Eugene Police Department · Eugene, OR
In a livestream update, the channel host says he returned to Eugene, Oregon in mid-July and was arrested outside a building by the same lieutenant who had earlier trespassed him in a prior video. He states the lieutenant and another officer arrested him without speaking to him first. He says he is now facing a municipal trespassing charge, pleaded not guilty, and has a court date the following month. He also claims the arresting officer turned off his body camera at the jail and criticized him, and he calls the arrest retaliatory. No footage of the arrest is shown in this video, and the account comes only from the host.
- Officer cautions auditor about touching parked vehicles
Yreka Police Department · Yreka, CA
As the lieutenant says he is leaving, he cautions the auditor about touching other people's vehicles and cites a vehicle code section, which he gives as 10852, saying tampering is a misdemeanor. The auditor says he was checking tires and that the vehicles are public ones marked CA exempt. The officer says he has discretion and is only cautioning, and invites the auditor to visit the PD for a tour. The two exchange sarcastic remarks, and the officer leaves without any citation or arrest.
- Police check on filming auditor at San Mateo Medical Center after security call
San Mateo Police Department · San Mateo, CA
Hospital security officers asked a man filming in the hospital's public areas why he was recording, and a security officer later told him recording was not allowed inside and that police would be involved if he continued. The man said recording is a constitutional right and told the officer to call police if they wished. An officer who identified himself with badge 181 arrived, said the man was filming in a public area and was fine to be there as long as nobody was being harmed. The officer asked him not to record private patient information and said he would speak with the security staff. The narrator describes the officer as professional.
- Yreka officer questions auditor recording inside school district office
Yreka Police Department · Yreka, CA
A man filming inside a Yreka Union High School District office was approached by a uniformed officer, who asked what he was doing, asked for ID, and questioned his right to record inside a building. The auditor declined to identify himself and said he had every right to record. The auditor states he later overheard the officer tell district employees the best way to deal with him was to ignore him and not speak to him. The auditor then confronted the officer, who said the auditor should not tell him how to do his job, and the two argued. The auditor then made a verbal public records request to staff, which was taken in writing.
Departments involved (5)
- Eugene Police Department
Eugene, OR
- San Francisco Police Department
San Francisco, CA
- San Mateo County Sheriff's Office
San Mateo County, CA
- San Mateo Police Department
San Mateo, CA
- Yreka Police Department
Yreka, CA
Officers named (0)
No officers identified yet.
CopFax documents incidents from Bay Area Transparency's publicly available videos, with 9 incidents reviewed and published so far. Each incident page embeds the original video and credits the creator.
Get listed: creators can ask CopFax to document their channel.
CopFax lists independent creators who cover police and civil-rights topics. Their views are their own, and listing a channel isn't an endorsement.