Commentary
Audit the Court
YouTube @auditthecourt (opens in a new tab)
CommentaryYouTube
- Type
- Commentary
- Platform
- YouTube
- Incidents documented on CopFax
- 3
- Departments involved
- 3
- Officers named
- 1
- YouTube subscribers
- 203,000
Incidents (3)
- Detroit officers arrest security guard after weapon light reportedly flashed toward patrol van; court finds no probable cause
June 2, 2025 · Detroit Police Department · Detroit, MI
The narrator states that on June 2, 2025, Detroit Police officers on a downtown detail saw a weapon-mounted light on a rifle flash toward them and approached a security guard. Officers testified they spoke with him from their van, then got out, had him retrieve the rifle from an SUV, found a second pistol in a pat-down, handcuffed him and placed him in a transport van. Officer Sterns testified the arrest was for felonious assault on a police officer, and that officers told the man they did not think the act was intentional. At a March 25, 2026 suppression hearing, the judge found the officers credible but concluded there was no probable cause for that arrest. The judge suppressed breath test results, and the narrator states the civil infraction was dismissed without prejudice and the property ordered returned.
- Timberlake officers extend tow truck stop and use drug dog; evidence suppressed at hearing
March 26, 2025 · Timberlake Police Department · Timberlake, OH
The narrator states that on March 26, 2025, Timberlake Police officers stopped a flatbed tow truck carrying a passenger's SUV, citing the lack of a four-point tie down and an expired registration. The passenger, whose license was suspended, was frisked and questioned for about 8 to 10 minutes; nothing illegal was found and he had no warrants. A drug dog was brought from Willoughby, and testimony indicated it alerted on a toolbox on the tow truck, not the SUV, which was raised on the flatbed. The SUV was lowered, officers reported seeing a pipe or bong in plain view, and a search found a firearm and drugs. At a July 21, 2025 hearing, the judge found there was no valid reason for the search and granted the motion to suppress, and the prosecutor later dismissed all charges, according to the narrator.
- Ormond Beach officer throws DUI arrestee to floor during breath test, later sentenced for felony battery
December 6, 2024 · Ormond Beach Police Department · Ormond Beach, FL
The narrator states that on December 6, 2024, an officer arrested a woman for DUI after a crash and took her to the station for a breath test. During the 20-minute observation period she was described as verbally hostile, and when she stood and refused an order to return to her seat, a second officer threw her to the ground. She received a forehead laceration that needed seven stitches and has a permanent scar. The first officer reported her belief that the force was excessive, and the second officer was placed on leave and later resigned. He was charged with felony battery, pleaded no contest, and on July 29, 2025 was sentenced to 6 months in county jail and 2 years of probation. At sentencing the judge found he had given supervisors an account the video did not support.
Departments involved (3)
- Detroit Police Department
Detroit, MI
- Ormond Beach Police Department
Ormond Beach, FL
- Timberlake Police Department
Timberlake, OH
Officers named (1)
- Melissa Edmonds
Officer, Ormond Beach Police Department
CopFax documents incidents from Audit the Court's publicly available videos, with 3 incidents reviewed and published so far. Each incident page embeds the original video and credits the creator.
Get listed: creators can ask CopFax to document their channel.
CopFax lists independent creators who cover police and civil-rights topics. Their views are their own, and listing a channel isn't an endorsement.