Skip to content

Detention at crime scene; use of force

Santa Paula detective removes retired firefighter giving CPR at crime scene and detains him

Email this report

Department Accountability Report

CommentaryAudit the Audit YouTube profile pictureSource video: Audit the Audit (opens in a new tab) (CopFax creator page) ยท Watch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)
Location
Parking lot crime scene in Santa Paula, California
Department
Santa Paula Police Department
Rights involved
Fourth Amendment
Outcome
No charges against the detained man. Federal excessive force claim against the detective dismissed on qualified immunity (March 24, 2023). City settled for an undisclosed amount in June 2023.

Summary

The narrator states that in October 2020 a retired firefighter stopped to give CPR to a shooting victim in a parking lot in Santa Paula. A detective arrived, ordered him out of the crime scene, and a tense verbal exchange followed. Officers escorted him away, and after he shouted at the detective from outside the lot, the detective approached him and officers handcuffed him and held him in a patrol car for about 15 minutes. The narrator says he suffered a dislocated shoulder and torn labrum needing surgery, and was not charged. The narrator reports a federal judge granted the detective qualified immunity on the excessive force claim, the city settled in June 2023 with non-disclosure agreements, and the detective later joined Baldwin Park PD.

CopFax assessment (opinion)

How police handled it

Not yet assessed

This is CopFax's opinion based on the source video and records linked on this page. The factual summary above is separate from this assessment.

Officers involved

No officers identified yet.

Related public records

No public records linked yet.

Report an error