Skip to content

Investigative stop and arrest for refusing to provide ID

Huntsville officers demand ID from mechanic repairing car in church lot

Email this report

Department Accountability Report

CommentaryAudit the Audit YouTube profile pictureSource video: Audit the Audit (opens in a new tab) (CopFax creator page) ยท Watch on YouTube (opens in a new tab)
Date
June 10, 2019
Location
Parking lot of Progressive Union Missionary Baptist Church
Department
Huntsville Police Department
Rights involved
Fourth Amendment
Outcome
Obstruction charge dismissed. Federal civil suit: 11th Circuit denied qualified immunity; jury awarded $77,000 in October 2024 ($75,000 pain and suffering plus $1,000 punitive damages against each officer, per narrator).

Summary

The narrator states that on June 10, 2019, a church security guard called 911 about two men working on a car in the church parking lot. Officers from the Huntsville Police Department arrived and repeatedly asked a mechanic for a driver's license or ID, which he declined to give while offering explanations of why he was there. The narrator says he was arrested and charged with obstruction, and that the charge was later dismissed. The narrator reports that the 11th Circuit denied qualified immunity and that a jury in October 2024 awarded him $77,000 in total damages.

CopFax assessment (opinion)

How police handled it

Not yet assessed

This is CopFax's opinion based on the source video and records linked on this page. The factual summary above is separate from this assessment.

Officers involved

No officers identified yet.

Related public records

No public records linked yet.

Report an error